Modern YEAR EIGHT

1996

_______________________________

–REFERENCE: In Blackest Night #1. The JLA defeats elderly 1940s science villain Brainwave (aka Brain Wave).

–FLASHBACK: From 52 #30. Joker’s pop-crime phase continues as he opts to commit another (unspecified) non-lethal silly gag as a challenge to the Dynamic Duo. Batman and Robin still knock him on his ass.

–REFERENCE: In Batgirl: Year One #4, Batgirl: Year One #9, and Nightwing Vol. 2 #104. Inside the Batcave, Batman, Robin, and Alfred (likely with metahuman assistance) build an entire city block-sized stage set, complete with buildings, fake people cut-outs, self-driving cars, automated machine guns, robot rogues, and live explosives. This phony but realistic city setting will serve as the ultimate training ground/obstacle course for the Dynamic Duo. Batman also connects security cameras showing live feeds of the course to viewing screens in Wayne Manor above. Batman and Robin begins running the course, building up a range of statistics and scores for themselves. Batman will continuously update the course statistics whenever someone runs it, moving forward.

–REFERENCE: In Silver Age: Teen Titans #1. Batman and Robin complete the case known as the “Incident of the Two Stilettos.” No details are given.

–FLASHBACK: From Batgirl: Year One #1 and the second feature to Birds of Prey #127. Babs spies on Batman while he meets with her dad on top of the GCPD HQ rooftop. It’s all preparation for her upcoming huge debut as a superhero.

–REFERENCE: In Batgirl: Year One #2. Batman saves a random person from a random robber.

–NOTE: In a flashback from Arkham Asylum: Living Hell. Finally, Barbara Gordon debuts as Batgirl. In this awesome 2003 tale by Dan Slott and Ryan Sook, Batgirl encounters the strange Humpty Dumpty (Humphry Dumpler), who has the innocent mind of a child. When Humpty Dumpty unwittingly destroys most of Gotham’s gaudy oversized advertisement statues and signs and then kills his grandmother, Batgirl brings him in to Arkham Asylum. Batman isn’t involved in this case and won’t meet Batgirl until her public debut, which comes shortly afterward.

–FLASHBACK: From Teen Titans Spotlight #14. February 7. Batman and Robin work the “Green Dragon Case” in Chinatown during the wild Chinese New Year celebration. Batman and Robin get chained up in a basement, but they free themselves by burning their manacles with acid.

–FLASHBACK: From Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 and the second feature to Birds of Prey #127. Originally told in Detective Comics #359. While en route to Bristol Country Club, the host location of a GCPD masquerade ball, Bruce is ambushed by Killer Moth and his hired Mothmen goons. Batgirl saves Bruce from Killer Moth.

–Batgirl: Year One #1-2 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)^[1][2]
Picking up directly from our previous item, the GCPD’s masquerade ball at Bristol Country Club begins. Many Gotham celebs are present, including the obnoxious socialite J Devlin Davenport. Bruce is dressed up as a Pierrot clown. Killer Moth strikes yet again, this time directly at the partygoers. As before, Batgirl protects Bruce and takes on Killer Moth, fighting the bug-themed villain into the woods adjacent to the club property. Batgirl manages to best Killer Moth, but the villain escapes thanks to help from his henchmen. Immediately afterward, Batgirl is confronted by Batman and Robin. This item is also shown via flashback from Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 and referenced in Batman: Batgirl, The Batman Files, and DC First: Batgirl/Joker #1. However, note that Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 doesn’t show Robin with Batman, which is an error due to retcon by Batgirl: Year One. The major errors in Batgirl: Year One #1-2 include Jim Gordon as captain and Batman wearing the wrong costume.

–Batgirl: Year One #3 Part 1 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)
Picking up directly from Batgirl: Year One #2, in the forest outside of Bristol Country Club, Batman and Robin greet Batgirl, not sure quite what to make of her. When a defeated but still lurking Killer Moth begins shooting at the trio from a helicopter, Batgirl flees the scene and returns home. After a brief encounter with GCPD Officer Jason Bard, an exhausted Babs crashes for the night. The next day, Batgirl is the talk of the town. Killer Moth meets with gangster Tony Bressi, who mocks the super-villain and has his henchmen send him packing. Later, Batman meets with Commissioner Gordon to discuss Killer Moth and Batgirl. Gordon mentions the need for a hotline to better communicate with Batman, but this is either a bad joke or a bad continuity error. Batman gave Gordon a hotline phone in Year One, but Gordon hated it and only used it once. Meanwhile, Batgirl busts some robbers and gets reported on by TV news journalist Roy Raymond Jr (son of the famed private eye). Bressi’s men beat up Killer Moth, adding injury to insult. Note that there is a hidden ellipsis in Batgirl: Year One #3 that occurs (starting now) in order to fit in a few other stories before Batgirl: Year One continues. Also note that the continuity errors of Jim Gordon being referred to as “captain” and Batman wearing the wrong costume both persist. This item is also shown via flashback from Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20, but, as mentioned above, it only shows Batman (omitting Robin)—plus the scene plays out a bit differently too. The canon version of Batgirl’s first ever meeting with the Dynamic Duo is the one depicted in Batgirl: Year One.

–“Photo Finish” by Devin Grayson/Duncan Fegredo (The Batman Chronicles #9 Part 1) Summer 1997
This one is for the ‘shippers! And one of my favorite Batman stories of all time. Devin Grayson, one of the few females that got a chance to make a big mark in a male-dominated industry, is a master at writing the Batman/Catwoman relationship. Her erotic depiction of their relationship goes well beyond innuendo, and it’s fun and amazing. Grayson, for my money, is one of the best Bat-writers in the history of the biz. In “Photo Finish,” Batman and Robin chase Catwoman. Batman tackles the runaway thief, putting her in a very compromising position. He then orders Robin to leave, so that he can um… er… “interrogate” her one-on-one. The bummed Robin cartwheels away into the night and runs into Batgirl. (This story originally depicted their very first meeting, but Batgirl: Year One retconned things. As such, we must ignore any dialogue referring to this being their first encounter. Technically, this is their second encounter.) Batgirl and Robin officially team-up (!), stop some burglars, and get pictures taken in a photo booth! The end. Great stuff.

–Batgirl: Year One #3 Part 2 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)
Batgirl prepares to conduct her first ever rope dive off the top of Wayne Tower. Lurking in the shadows, Batman and Robin watch her with keen interest.

–Batgirl: Year One #4 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)
Picking up directly from Batgirl: Year One #3 Part 2, Batgirl tries her first ever rope dive off of a tall skyscraper and botches it. Luckily, Batman and Robin are watching and save her (by cutting her rope and catching her). Batman and Robin then proceed to knock out Batgirl and take her to Batcave. Robin briefly chats with Batgirl, showing her around a bit. (We see images of villains on the Bat-computer, including an image Matt Hagen that is incorrectly listed as Basil Karlo.) The Dynamic Duo tests Batgirl’s abilities via an obstacle course. Alfred warns Batman that he’d better not invite any more child soldiers into the fold. Batman lies and tells Batgirl he’s not quite satisfied with her test results, after which the Dynamic Duo knocks her out again and returns her home (learning her secret ID in the process). Later, under Batman’s orders, Robin sends Babs some Bat-equipment in the mail and gives her a personal letter of approval. As referenced in Batgirl: Year One #6, Batman is indeed impressed with and already approves of Batgirl for the most part, but he doesn’t want her to know it yet. (This issue is also shown via flashback from Nightwing Vol. 2 #75 and Superman/Batman #75 Part 4.) Note that there is a two-month-long ellipsis between Batgirl: Year One #4 and Batgirl: Year One #5 in order to accommodate other tales and to jibe with the upcoming debut of the JL Satellite.

–REFERENCE: In Batman & Superman: World’s Finest #4-10. Late March. Batman and Superman, as they do every year, meet to commemorate the death of Dr. Harrison Grey.

–“Folie à deux” by Kelley Puckett/Terry Dodson (Legends of the DC Universe #10-11) November 1998 to December 1998
Our story opens with Barbara Gordon, who has just turned 18-years-old, at Gotham State University. (Writer Kelley Puckett shows Babs seemingly about to start a new semester at college, but we are definitely in spring, so Babs has to be continuing her already-in-progress semester, not starting a new one.) In any case, the big news is that Babs is now moving on campus, leaving her dad’s place for the first time ever. Welcome to dorm life! (According to canon, Babs graduated high school early at age fifteen and immediately began an early-entry college program just after turning sixteen. Now eighteen, Babs will soon complete undergraduate degrees in computer science, data science, and pre-law, after which she will immediately begin advanced law and ALA-accredited library science Master’s degree programs.) Commissioner Gordon is unsure if his daughter is Batgirl. He has a feeling but is scared to approach her about it, so he never does. Batman, on the other hand, having now worked side-by-side with Batgirl and seen her in action several times, does approach the young woman and warns her to quit the superhero game, saying that she will get killed without proper training. Babs agrees and they strike up a deal. Batman will begin training Batgirl as long as she puts the costume away until he deems her ready. (Batman and Batgirl working out this training deal is also shown via flashback from Birds of Prey: Batgirl/Catwoman #1.) Batgirl goes through Batman’s initial training course, but, only a day later, Gordon is put into a terrifying hostage situation and Batgirl feels she has no choice other than to break her vow. Batgirl saves her dad, causing Batman to promptly end her training.

–REFERENCE: In Batgirl: Year One #9—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #78. The snake-themed villain known as Copperhead debuts and is defeated by Batman, Batgirl, and Wonder Woman. Note that Batgirl: Year One #9 references Copperhead’s debut versus Batman, but it implies that Batgirl isn’t involved. However, Copperhead’s original debut (The Brave and The Bold #78) involved Batgirl and Wonder Woman. The 2008 DC Comics Encyclopedia, although hardly a true canonical source, says outright that Copperhead’s debut in the Modern Age reflects his Silver Age origin, which includes Batgirl’s presence. Pick your poison here, but I’ve chosen to reflect The Brave and The Bold #78.

–FLASHBACK: From Wonder Woman Vol. 3 #34—and referenced in Stars & STRIPE #9, Stars & STRIPE #0, Justice League of America Vol. 2 #0, and the second feature to 52 #38. Originally told in Justice League of America #64-66. Evil scientist Dr. TO Morrow (Dr. Tomek Ovadya Morah) creates the android Red Tornado, sending him to infiltrate the JLA and JSA to destroy both from within. Note that Red Tornado is a combination of the Air/Wind Elemental known as Ulthoon (aka Tornado Tyrant aka Tornado Champion) and the android host body built by Morrow. As the second feature to 52 #38 tells us, Morrow gave Red Tornado sentience, but Ulthoon gave him morality. Red Tornado realizes he is being controlled and helps the JLA and JSA defeat Morrow. After Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman specifically detain Morrow, rather than humiliate and pummel the defenseless super-scientist, they treat him with relative kindness, trying to understand his perspective. Morrow will still go to prison, but Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman will always have a semblance of respect for Morrow that they usually won’t have for other villains.

–REFERENCE: In Silver Age: Teen Titans #1. Officials from the private beachside community of Seaside reach out to Bruce, hoping to get him to purchase property there. Bruce and Dick review Seaside’s official rules and regulations (a tome of overly strict ordinances and mandates), finding them to be quite bizarre. Bruce passes on buying property there.

–REFERENCE: In Batman Confidential #19. In conversation with Batgirl, the Caped Crusader gives positive praise to Catwoman, calling her the “Robin Hood of Alleytown.”

–“The Silver Age” by D Curtis Johnson, Michael Collins, & Vince Russell (Silver Age: Secret Files & Origins #1) July 2000^[3]
With Kanjar Ro’s help, powerful cosmic super-villain Agamemno spies on the Justice League of America as each member fights his or her rival. (The villains shown are Lex Luthor, Black Manta, Chronos, Dr. Light, Felix Faust, Mr. Element, Sinestro, Catwoman, and Penguin.) Batman specifically battles and defeats Penguin. Note that Mr. Element is Dr. Alchemy, but, at this juncture, he likely would only be using his Dr. Alchemy name. So either he’s temporarily switched back for the Silver Age series or this is a major continuity error. It’s your personal headcanon call, but, for simplicity’s sake, we’ll assume he’s made a temporary switch. Later, Agamemno continues spying on the JLA as they defeat Despero on an unnamed distant planet. (This item is also shown via flashback from Silver Age #1.)

–“The Silver Age: Pawns of the Invincible Immortal!” by Mark Waid, Terry Dodson, Rachel Dodson, & John Kalisz (Silver Age #1) July 2000
This item picks up directly from Silver Age: Secret Files & Origins #1. Having gathered his intel on the Justice League, Agamemno travels to Earth and forms the Injustice League—not to be confused with the Injustice Society, which is an entirely separate team. Agamemno’s IJL team consists of Lex Luthor, Black Manta, Chronos, Dr. Light, Felix Faust, Mr. Element (aka Dr. Alchemy), Penguin, Sinestro, and Catwoman. Agamemno causes the IJL to magickally swap minds and bodies with the JLA. Batman gets specifically stuck in Penguin’s body. (As mentioned above, Chief Miles Clancy O’Hara is shown here, but this is a continuity error. This should be the younger relative of Miles Clancy—simply known as Officer O’Hara.) An aloof Snapper Carr meets with the body-swapped villains in the Secret Sanctuary, but he can’t tell the difference, even going so far as to send out an alert to the superhero community to go after the “villains,” who regroup in the Batcave.

–“The Silver Age: The Tyrannical Terror of Sheriff Law” by Marv Wolfman, Patrick Olliffe, Andrew Hennessey, & Carla Feeny (Silver Age: Teen Titans #1) July 2000
This item picks up shortly after Silver Age #1 and immediately following the Batman-less Silver Age: Justice League of America #1. Having swapped minds and bodies with their rivals (and thus learned their rivals’ secret identities), the Injustice League has just taken out the Green Lantern Corps and committed genocide on the entire shrunken populace of Rikkon Dor (a bottled Kryptonian city). The Justice League (stuck in super-villain bodies) tries and fails to make contact with the Teen Titans, who are in the middle of dealing with John Law, a corrupt sheriff of a beachside community. (Sheriff John Law is not to be confused with elder superhero John Law aka The Tarantula.) Sheriff Law and his elite squad of troops captures the Teen Titans. When Batman (in Penguin’s body), Flash (in Mr. Element/Dr. Alchemy’s body), and Aquaman (in Black Manta’s body) arrive, it’s not long before they are fighting their own sidekicks, who have been temporarily mentally-manipulated by Sheriff Law’s weird super-science gadgetry. Eventually, Sheriff Law and his men are defeated, but Batman and company are also forced to flee, unable to convince their teen partners of their true identities. (A flashback from Silver Age: Flash #1 Part 2 contains a generic image that is meant to show Silver Age: Teen Titans #1, but the different Silver Age creative teams were clearly not fully communicating with one another because the flashback doesn’t actually show a real moment from the story. Sigh.)

–“The Silver Age: Mystery of the Thieving Thunderbolt” by Brian Augustyn, Norm Breyfogle, & Carla Feeny (Silver Age: Flash #1 Part 2) July 2000
Note that the Batman-less Silver Age: Flash #1 Part 1 is wholly separate from the Silver Age arc, featuring a random Flash tale from two-and-a-half years ago. Picking up a few days after Silver Age: Teen Titans #1, Silver Age: Flash #1 Part 2 begins with Mr. Element/Dr. Alchemy (in Flash’s body) committing a series of robberies, thus ruining Flash’s reputation. Realizing something ain’t right, Kid Flash and Elongated Man are on the case. Meanwhile, the real Flash (in Mr. Element’s body) hides out with Batman (in Penguin’s body), catching up with the latest news (which randomly includes a negative headline about Donald Trump). Soon after, Mr. Element tries to ruin Flash’s reputation further at a charity gala, but Kid Flash, Elongated Man, and the real Flash intervene. Flash isn’t able to convince his friends about the body-swap, but his efforts are enough to make the public think that Mr. Element was behind all the Flash robberies. As referenced in Silver Age: Showcase #1 and Silver Age: The Brave and The Bold #1, the public, still in the dark about the mind/body-swapping, comes to believe that all Justice League members except for Batman and Flash have gone rogue. Besides those two, all other JLA-ers are labeled as wanted criminals.

–“The Silver Age: The Great Gotham Switcheroo!” by Bob Haney, Kevin Maguire, Mark Farmer, & James Sinclair (Silver Age: The Brave and The Bold #1) (July 2000)
Batman (currently stuck in Penguin’s body) isn’t actually in this one, but Penguin (galavanting around in Batman’s body) is featured. I’ve chosen to include this, but it’s up to you whether or not you consider a book with only Batman’s body but not his mind as a legitimate Batman title. This item picks up directly from Silver Age: Flash #1 Part 2. A confused US military, thinking that the Justice League (except for Batman) has gone rogue, sends the Metal Men to assist the Dark Knight against Catwoman (actually a body-swapped Black Canary) and Felix Faust (actually a body-swapped Green Arrow). Batman (actually a body-swapped Penguin) is joined by the Metal Men. While Penguin plays hero in an effort to fool the Metal Men, Green Arrow casts a spell that turns the Metal Men into humans. Dr. Will Magnus changes the Metal Men back into robot forms. While Black Canary and Green Arrow make their escape, Penguin randomly sheds his Bat-bod and reverts back to his tubby tuxedo-wearing self. What has occurred? As referenced in Silver Age: Green Lantern #1, Hal Jordan has just used Sinestro’s Yellow Lantern power ring and the Green Lantern Central Power Battery to undo Agamemno’s mind/body swap. As such, the JLA and IJL have all switched back to their proper bodies.

–“The Silver Age: The 7 Soldiers of Victory” by Geoff Johns, Dick Giordano, & Tom McCraw (Silver Age: Showcase #1) (July 2000)
This item picks up directly from Silver Age: The Brave and The Bold #1 and the Batman-less Silver Age: Green Lantern #1. In the Happy Harbor Sanctuary, Snapper Carr is shocked to find that Batman has morphed into Penguin. The bird-themed super-villain captures Snapper and communicates with his Injustice League brethren, unaware that a visiting Deadman is secretly listening. Deadman learns that the IJL is planning to use the Green Lantern Central Power Battery, a Kryptonian jewel, and a Thanagarian device known as the Absorbascon for nefarious purposes on the planet Rann. Inspired by the 1940s superhero team known as The Seven Soldiers of Victory (aka Law’s Legionnaires), Deadman decides to build a seven-person anti-IJL team. He starts by recruiting Adam Strange (who is purchasing an engagement ring for his girlfriend Alanna). Deadman then visits Dr. Bryndon Smith and Shining Knight (Gardner Grayle) at STAR Labs, recruiting the latter. Deadman next recruits Batgirl, after which he visits Element Girl (Urania Blackwell) and Metamorpho, recruiting the latter. Deadman rounds out the team with Mento and Blackhawk (Janos Prohaska). On Rann, the new Seven Soldiers of Victory and the Green Lantern Corps (Hal Jordan, Chaselon, Medphyll, Tomar-Re, Katma Tui, Stel, Penelops, NautKeLoi, and Galius Zed) combat the IJL, but the villains are able to use the three powerful items to defeat the heroes. The GLC is imprisoned in outer space near Rann. Agamemno is fully-absorbed into the Green Lantern Central Power Battery. The villains permanently remove the Green Lantern Central Power Battery’s weakness against the color yellow. They also gain godlike knowledge, learning the secret identities of every single superhero alive.

–“The Silver Age: S.O.S. to Nowhere!” by Mark Waid, Eduardo Barreto, & Glenn Whitmore (Silver Age 80-Page Giant #1 Part 1) July 2000
This item picks up directly from Silver Age: Showcase #1. Snapper Carr and the new Seven Soldiers of Victory remotely brief the Justice League about the actions of the Injustice League, who consolidate their new godlike authority by creating power rings for themselves. Fearing an attack from the IJL, the JLA decides to reveal their secret IDs to their loved ones, taking them all to Gorilla City to go under King Solovar‘s protection. Among those gathered for security are: Ma and Pa Kent (Martha Kent and Jonathan Kent), Mera, the newborn Aquababy (Arthur Curry Jr), Alfred, Commissioner Gordon, Jean Loring, Iris West, Dinah Drake Lance, Diane Meade, Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen, and Perry White. (Flash’s parents, Nora and Henry Allen, are included here, but this is an atrocious continuity error since both his parents are dead. They were alive in the Silver/Bronze Age, which is what writer Mark Waid is likely cutely making reference to here, but this is the Modern Age, so we must ignore their cameo.) Superman, Aquaman, and the Teen Titans fail to defend the Atlantic Coast against Black Manta and Sinestro. Green Arrow, Black Canary, Batgirl, and Mento are bested by Penguin and Dr. Light at Solar City, a massive clean energy installation designed by Dr. Bruce Gordon and Dr. Simon Bennett. Martian Manhunter, Flash, Elongated Man, and the Metal Men lose to Chronos and Mr. Element/Dr. Alchemy in Moscow. The Russian heads of state are temporarily turned into babies. (We are in 1996, so any mention of the Soviet Union must be ignored. And, because we are in 1996, we can presume that Boris Yeltsin and Vladimir Putin, among others, are present.) Batman (disguised as Niles Caulder), the Atom, Metamorpho, and the Doom Patrol are defeated by Felix Faust, Catwoman, and Lex Luthor in Paris. After regrouping, the JLA uses the powerful H-Dial to turn themselves into brand new alter-egos. (Young Robby Reed hand delivers the H-Dial to the JLA, but this is a giant continuity error that must be summarily ignored. Robby won’t debut until later. In fact, Robby even has a Batman-less Silver Age: Dial H for Hero #1 issue that is entirely non-canon.) In their new superhero identities, the JLA is able to defeat the IJL. A charged-up Agamemno then emerges from the Green Lantern Central Power Battery and attacks. (This battle is also shown via flashforward from Silver Age: The Challengers of the Unknown #1.) Aided by Hawkman, Hawkgirl, a platoon of Thanagarians, and the Green Lantern Corps, the JLA takes the fight to Agamemno. (Notably, the JLA reacts to the Thanagarians as if they’ve never seen nor heard about them before, which makes no sense at all and must be regarded as yet another terrible continuity error. In fact, Hawkman and Hawkgirl are current members of the JLA! Waid doubles down on this, having Superman introduce himself to Hawkman, saying that he hopes to have Thanagarians on the JLA lineup some day. Again, ignore this!) Leaning on the idea that he was manipulated by Agamemno, Luthor will see no jail time. The combination of Hal’s power ring and the Absorbascon then causes a natural erasure of the villains’ knowledge of all the heroes’ secret IDs. The green-powered Absorbascon also erases the knowledge of the heroes’ secret IDs from the minds of their close friends and family members. However, this entire end sequence of Silver Age 80-Page Giant #1 Part 1 has been heavily retconned thanks to references in Identity Crisis #6-7 and JLA #46. Thanks to these retcons, the green-powered Absorbascon doesn’t actually fix everything with a neatly tied bow. This happy ending is actually a carefully crafted lie. In reality, the heroes were unable to undo having their secret IDs exposed. Therefore, the villains (and presumably all the JLA’s friends and family too!) are mind-wiped by team-ally Zatanna. As revealed in Identity Crisis, Zatanna has been previously called upon by certain members of the JLA to mind-wipe villains, erasing their memories of certain delicate cases—especially ones (like this) that feature the exposure of secret IDs. In recent months, the JLA had gotten into a bad habit of erasing villains’ memories after their secret IDs had been outed. For example, Floronic Man, Matter Master, Felix Faust, Brainwave, and Dr. Destiny have all been mind-wiped before. Importantly, though, Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman don’t know a thing about these mind-wipes, nor do they know about the wipes that have just occurred. The rest of the JLA (and Zatanna) knows the Trinity would definitely not approve of scrambling people’s brains. Therefore, they have been hiding (and continue to hide) a very grave (and ongoing) series of actions from the Trinity. As referenced in Identity Crisis #6-7 and JLA #46, the Agamemno mind/body swap affair is the direct catalyst that causes Batman to now begin collecting detailed info on his superhero pals and formulating contingency plans in case something like this should happen again. Batman’s distrust of his friends is a mere twinkle in his eye at this point, but it will grow as the years roll on. The notorious “Mind-Wipe Scandal” hast just begun, but it’s a powder keg with multiple parts that will continue into the future. (The next parts of the “mind-wipe scandal” will be told next year, primarily via flashbacks from Identity Crisis and The OMAC Project.)

–REFERENCE: In JLA Incarnations #2—originally told in Superman #199. Superman races Flash in a UN-sponsored charity race across the globe. The race ends in a tie.

–REFERENCE: In DC Comics Presents: Green Lantern #1 Part 1—originally told in Flash #175. Reverse-Flash (aka Professor Zoom aka Eobard Thawne) and Abra Kadabra kidnap the Justice League of America and force Flash and Superman into having a rematch of their recent running race, only this time they must race through the whole expanse of the universe. Upon returning home and finishing the race, again in a dead tie, Superman and Flash bust the villains and save their friends. Superman and Flash will have many more races over the course of the following years, although none will be quite as public as their first two.

–“A Penny For Your Thoughts, a Dollar For Your Destiny!” by Brian Azzarello, Norm Breyfogle, Sal Buscema, & Tony Aviña (DC Comics Presents: Green Lantern #1 Part 1) September 2004
Hal Jordan decides to bait a fugitive Gorilla Grodd with a ridiculous ruse that involves selling supposedly functional Green Lantern power rings to everyday citizens on a Coast City street corner. The ring sale creates quite a public stir, drawing not only Grodd but a confused Justice League of America (Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, and Flash) as well. Hal’s teammates’ confusion (although not their surprise) subsides as the scheme works as planned. Hal busts Grodd, who tries to obtain one of the rings while wearing a terrible disguise. Afterward, Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, and Flash take a ride in Diana’s invisible jet, criticizing Hal’s lack of imagination while discussing his goofy albeit successful scheme. Wonder Woman says she’s forgotten to pick-up Aquaman, revealing that this has happened before. Superman, Wonder Woman, and Flash each have a laugh thinking about what they’d do with a Green Lantern power ring. But when they think about Batman having one, the laughing instantly ceases.

–JLA Incarnations #2 by John Ostrander, Val Semeiks, Prentis Rollins, & John Kalisz (August 2001)^[4]
Batman helps his JLA teammates to fight a time-traveling talking dinosaur called Fire-Eye. Upon arrival to the battlefield, Batman sees Green Arrow and Black Canary working hand-in-hand, noting to himself that working with a partner seems too risky. Yes, Robin has debuted, so the Caped Crusader already has a partner. As such, this is a major continuity error. Superman shows up to help finish off Fire-Eye. (The fight against Fire-Eye is also shown via flashback from JLA Incarnations #5 Part 2.) We then see Superman publicly join the JLA full-time during an interview with journalist Tully Reed. Again, Superman is already a full-time member, so this must be ignored as a continuity error. The next day, Batman teams with the JLA to defeat Gorilla Grodd in Washington DC. Afterward, we see Batman officially join the JLA full-time, but, like Superman, he’s already a full-time member, so this too must be ignored as a continuity error.

–FLASHBACK: From JLA Classified #51 and JLA Classified #53-54. The JLA battles the evil “god” known as Titus, who transports the team to the Moon and proceeds to savagely beat them. Eventually though, the JLA regroups and achieves victory. Afterward, the team buries the corpse of Titus on the Moon. Note that, for the first time ever, Green Arrow sports what will become his signature goatee.^[5]

–REFERENCE: In Hourman #16. The JLA figures out how to operate Kanjar Ro’s energy scepter, which is currently a trophy in the Secret Sanctuary. The team records the scientific details in a journal in the Happy Harbor library. JLA Classified #50-54 (our previous item) specifically says the team doesn’t know how the energy rod works, while the upcoming flashback from Hourman #16 (in which Joker tricks Snapper Carr) says they’ve figured it out—hence placement of this item here, prior to that flashback from Hourman #16.

–FLASHBACK: From Secret Origins Vol. 2 #50 Part 5—and referenced in Batgirl: Year One #6. Originally told in Justice League of America #73-74. The JLA and JSA team-up to defeat the radioactive cosmic monster known as Aquarius. Larry Lance (father to Black Canary II and husband to Black Canary I) dies during the fight. Note that the timeline from Secret Origins Vol. 2 #50 Part 5 is a bit wonky as it has the JLA moving into their satellite HQ, then Speedy’s heroin addiction, then the death of Larry Lance. This isn’t right no matter how you look at it. Originally, in the Silver Age, Larry’s death came first, then the satellite, then Speedy’s drug problem. The Modern Age correctly mirrors this order, so it’s very strange that Secret Origins Vol. 2 #50 Part 5 messes it up. Even odder and more off, JLA: Year One says outright that Larry’s death occurs much earlier, paradoxically prior to the formation of the JLA. That obviously must be ignored as well.

–FLASHBACK: From Hourman #16—originally told in Justice League of America #77. Joker, posing as the head of an anti-metahuman advocacy group called the Average Army, tricks Justice League mascot Snapper Carr to turn on the team and join his ranks. Snapper not only reveals the location of the JLA’s Secret Sanctuary in Happy Harbor, Rhode Island to Joker, but he also gives him the key to the front door! Joker steals a bunch of weapons from the sanctuary trophy room and uses them against the JLA during a battle outside of Arkham Asylum. After a tough fight, Joker is eventually defeated and incarcerated. The JLA is shocked and dismayed to learn of Snapper’s betrayal.

–FLASHBACK: From Hourman #8. Snapper Carr, having betrayed the JLA after being tricked by Joker a couple weeks ago, sits dejectedly in the no-longer secret Sanctuary in Happy Harbor. The JLA tells him it was an honest mistake, but Snapper decides to permanently leave his post as honorary member/mascot.

–REFERENCE: In JSA #54 and the second feature to 52 #34—originally told in Justice League of America #161. Zatanna helps the JLA defeat the Warlock of Ys, earning a proper spot on the JLA lineup. In the Silver Age, this item occurred much later on the timeline, but it goes here on the Modern Age timeline thanks to John Ostrander’s JLA Incarnations #3. Also of note, in the Silver Age, Elongated Man and Red Tornado joined the JLA before Zatanna, but JLA Incarnations #3 seems to have radically restructured the Modern Age by placing Zatanna’s inclusion on the JLA prior to the inclusion of Elongated Man and Red Tornado.

–REFERENCE: In JLA Incarnations #3 and Identity Crisis #6-7—originally told in Justice League of America #179. Thanks to a freak nuclear accident, high school student Ronnie Raymond and Nobel prize-winner Dr. Martin Stein become able to fuse together to become the superhero Firestorm. Firestorm joins the JLA. The team poses for an iconic photo with its newest member. In the Bronze Age, this item occurred much later on the timeline, but it goes here on the Modern Age timeline thanks to John Ostrander’s JLA Incarnations #3. Also of note, in the Silver/Bronze Age, Elongated Man and Red Tornado joined the JLA before Zatanna and Firestorm, but JLA Incarnations #3 seems to have radically restructured the Modern Age by placing Zatanna and Firestorm’s inclusion on the JLA prior to the inclusion of Elongated Man and Red Tornado.

–“Like a Tombstone in the Sky” by John Ostrander/Val Semeiks (JLA Incarnations #3) September 2001
Since the JLA’s HQ in Happy Harbor was compromised (thanks to Snapper Carr getting fooled by Joker) a few weeks ago, the team obtains international approval to create a very special new HQ.^[6] Now officially sanctioned by the US Government, the JLA builds and launches a new satellite headquarters into Earth’s orbit. Shortly after the launch of the satellite, the JLA defeats the debuting global terrorist organization/apocalypse cult known as the Kobra Cult. The Kobra Cult is led by Jeffrey Franklin Burr, who goes by “Lord Naga-Naga” or “Lord Kobra” but more commonly is known as just “Kobra.” The JLA defeats a large group of cultists, but Burr escapes. Later, Green Arrow does a TV interview and espouses some left wing rhetoric on behalf of the JLA, which puts the team in hot water with the UN. During a meeting aboard the new satellite (sans the Trinity), Hawkman and Green Arrow argue about politics and have to be separated before they come to blows. Enraged, Green Arrow quits the team! Lex Luthor then hires the Kobra Cult to attack the JLA satellite. Dozens of mini LexCorp spaceships strike at once and Kobra takes over the HQ, kidnapping Black Canary in the process. Green Arrow immediately rejoins the team to confront Lex. Batman and his JLA teammates visit Lex, who lies and says that Kobra stole his tech, thus avoiding any legal connection to wrongdoing. The JLA mounts-up and then goes to war against Kobra in orbit, eventually defeating them and retaking their floating home-base. Green Arrow is badly injured and rushed to a hospital where he claims that he has once again quit the JLA. Of course, this isn’t true, since we’ll see him again soon fighting side-by-side with his pals.

–Batgirl: Year One #6 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)^[7]
Batman and Robin give Batgirl a motorcycle to test her skills. (Batman still doesn’t want Batgirl to know that he supports her, so Robin handles the delivery.) Meanwhile, mobster Tony Bressi, eager to get rid of Commissioner Gordon but scared of being linked to the crime, orders two of his henchmen to dress up as Killer Moth and Firefly and kidnap Commissioner Gordon. The goons abduct Commissioner Gordon with ease and then set off an explosion at the former office of the deceased Larry Lance. The bombing kills Gordon’s friend Benny and permanently injures GCPD Officer Jason Bard. Black Canary chats with Green Arrow aboard the JL Satellite before teaming-up with Batgirl to chase the bad guys to Bressi’s mansion where Commissioner Gordon is being held. There, the real Killer Moth (escaped yet again) and Firefly show up to fight their copycats and clear their names.

–REFERENCE: In Batman Incorporated #4, Deadman Vol. 2 #1, and Batgirl: Year One #7—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #79 and Strange Adventures #214-216. Ra’s al Ghul’s second-in-command and biological father Han-Son (better known as The Sensei) has created an elite splinter faction of the League of Assassins. The Sensei and Ra’s al Ghul began butting heads, which led to the start of a cold war between the two. Cut to now. Batman meets the ghost superhero Deadman. Deadman is the spirit of Boston Brand, deceased circus aerialist and friend of the late Flying Graysons. Boston was recently murdered by League of Assassins member Hook and then turned into an undead hero by the Tibetan goddess Rama Kushna. Deadman urges a reluctant Batman to help him obtain revenge against Hook. Meanwhile, the Sensei’s men follow-up on their assassination to find Boston’s identical twin brother, Cleveland Brand, masquerading as Boston at the circus. (Cleveland has officially taken over his brother’s role at Hill’s Bros.) Believing that Hook has botched the hit, the Sensei executes Hook for his supposed failure. Batman and Deadman travel to the Himalayan mystical city of Nanda Parbat (home to Rama Kushna) where they deal with the Sensei and his League of Assassins faction, presumably learning about Hook’s fate.^[8]

–REFERENCE: In Batgirl: Year One #7-8. Batman doesn’t visually appear in Batgirl: Year One #7-8, but these issues are canon. From overseas, Batman orders Robin to keep tabs on Batgirl, who rescues her father with some help from Black Canary. Killer Moth and Firefly get away, and Tony Bressi walks with no evidence to link him to any wrongdoing. Robin tells Commissioner Gordon that Batman has not yet returned from adventuring with Deadman in Tibet (as noted in our previous item). An eager Robin then teams-up with a reluctant Batgirl. They ride motorcycles together and then take down the debuting Condiment King, after which Robin steals a kiss. Later, they assist the GCPD (and a debuting Officer Billy Pettit) in taking down Blockbuster, during which Batgirl acts with reckless abandon. Afterward, Vicki Vale interviews Commissioner Gordon, who later confirms Babs’ secret. (Gordon already basically knew, but had some doubt. Not any more.) An angry Gordon confronts his daughter at home, but Babs runs away before they can talk. Meanwhile, Firefly and Killer Moth set the police station on fire.

–Batgirl: Year One #9 by Scotty Beatty/Chuck Dixon/Marcos Martin (2003)
Picking up directly from Batgirl: Year One #8, the burning police station is saved and Firefly and Killer Moth are brought to justice by Batgirl (although Batman and Robin get the credit). Afterward, Batman and Robin finally have respect for Batgirl. The Dynamic Duo share their secret IDs with Batgirl and invite her into the Bat-Family. Batman and Robin then trick Commissioner Gordon into disbelieving his daughter is Batgirl—Robin dresses in drag to fool him! Don’t forget, this series contains the bad error of referring to Gordon as “captain.” This particular issue is even worse (or better?), referring to him as both “captain” and “lieutenant”! Later, Babs hangs out with Jason Bard, who has decided to become a private eye. Babs helps Jason moved into his new office, which is the former congressional campaign office of the corrupt Rupert Thorne, who will eventually take over the Gotham City mafia in the near future. Babs herself muses about running for Congress in the future, a nice bit of foreshadowing. Later that night, Batgirl teams with Batman and Robin to apprehend an escaped Scarecrow. (Despite having been previously been shown in his black insignia costume, Batman is now shown wearing his yellow oval costume—an eye-rolling Easter egg by writer Scott Beatty, his attempt to connect the yellow oval switch to his story. Batman should have had his yellow oval for the entirety of this arc.) We should note that, despite the trickery on the part of the Bat-Family, Jim Gordon still has an inkling that his daughter is Batgirl, although he won’t confirm it.

–REFERENCE: In Batman: Hidden Treasures #1 Part 2 (Swamp Thing #7).  Batman begins investigating the criminal organization known as The Conclave, trying to expose its mysterious leader, who aptly goes by the name “Mr. E.” Not so coincidentally, Nathan Ellery becomes a top executive at the Wayne Foundation. Unknown to all, Ellery is the secret Mr. E at the top of the Conclave. While we won’t see it on our timeline ahead, Batman will continue to investigate the Conclave for months to come.

–REFERENCE: In JLA #18 and The Batman Files—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #80 and 1st Issue Special #7. Batman teams-up with the Creeper to defeat the debuting Hellgrammite. From this point forward, Batman will closely monitor Creeper’s actions, including a Creeper solo fight against Firefly.

–FLASHBACK: From Power Company: Bork #1—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #81. Flash and Batman team-up to face Carl Bork.

–REFERENCE: In JLA #11—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #82. Batman and Aquaman team-up to defeat Aquaman’s half-brother Ocean Master (Orm Marius).

–REFERENCE: In Batman Confidential #20. The Russian Mob (i.e. the Russo-American mafia that will eventually become known as the “Odessa Mob”), led by top dog siblings Vassily Davidovitch and Anatoly Davidovitch, makes its presence known in Gotham City. Batman takes notice and begins keeping tabs.

–REFERENCE: In Justice League Quarterly #8—originally told in Justice League of America #70. Debuting teenage superhero Mind-Grabber Kid (Lucian Crawley) gets jealous when the veteran superheroes steal his headlines, which leads to him convincing some alien warriors that the JLA are a bunch of villains. While on a mission to check-up on the Creeper (remotely-guided by Batman), the JLA is ambushed and defeated by the aliens. Thanks to the Creeper’s help, Superman is able to rectify the ugly situation. Seeing the error of his ways, Mind-Grabber Kid admits his wrongdoing and all’s well that ends well.

–REFERENCE: In Batman Confidential #17-19. Batman goes on a top secret Justice League business—business that we never learn about. Once he wraps up his JLA dealings, he responds to a Gotham warehouse explosion, taking us directly into “The Cat and The Bat.”

–“The Cat and The Bat” by Fabian Nicieza/Kevin Maguire (Batman Confidential #19-21) July to November 2008
At few things to note before we dig in. First, this item occurs specifically three weeks since Batgirl was made an official member of the Bat-Family, hence placement here. Second, issue #21 specifically references Batgirl’s fight against Blockbuster from Batgirl: Year One #8. Third, writer Fabian Nicieza makes a reference about something that occurred to Babs during her junior year of college, which is sketchy since Babs’ genius-track schooling doesn’t lend itself to easy categorization. This college reference should probably be ignored. Fourth, this story reads as the first meeting between Batgirl and Catwoman, but this isn’t actually true. They first met during the recent “Silver Age” crossover. Okay, before the official synopsis, let’s get caught up to speed with what happened during the Batman-less Batman Confidential #17-18! Babs took her dad’s notebook diary (which contains his entire case-file history written in secret code) and tried to decipher it while on a boring shift at her job at the Gotham Library. Catwoman broke in and took the notebook from Babs, who donned her fighting togs and went into chase mode. Batgirl caught up with Catwoman and they sure didn’t get along. After a nude brawl at the Gotham Hedonist Society (!), the sirens were forced to team-up after the notebook was stolen by the Russian Mob. Catwoman explained that she needed info from Commissioner Gordon’s diary to expose the Russians, who have enslaved a girl named Elena. This led to a chaotic fight against the Russians, during which a warehouse exploded and began burning down. Cut to now—and our official synopsis for Batman Confidential #19-21! Batman returns from his JLA mission to scold the ladies in his life. The Caped Crusader (who is up to date on everything about the Russian organization thanks to his Bat-computer crime database) and Batgirl go after the bad guys. Soon after, the Russians get Riddler to decode Gordon’s notebook, but Batman, Batgirl, and Catwoman intervene. While Batman chases after Vassily Davidovitch and saves Elena, Batgirl chases Riddler and the notebook to Arkham Asylum. At Arkham, Riddler takes control of the entire building and releases all the prisoners from their cells. We see some great Maguire renditions of a lot of the inmates as Batgirl successfully defeats Catman, Cavalier, Signalman, Blockbuster, Two-Face, Clayface II, and Scarecrow! Batgirl also runs past a creepy Joker, avoiding a direct confrontation with him. Finally making it into Arkham’s control room, Batgirl is crestfallen to find Catwoman, notebook in hand, standing next to a knocked-out Riddler. As the sun rises, Batgirl listens in as Batman talks with Catwoman about his newest protégé, getting her to admit that Batgirl has got mad chops.

–REFERENCE: In The Batman Files. Some of the JLAers, notably Green Arrow (as we’ve recently seen in JLA Incarnations #3), are bothered by the political red tape involved with now being officially sanctioned by the US government. Batman is also very bothered by this red tape. Over time, his frustration will only grow in regard to this matter.

–FLASHBACK: From Hourman #16. With Snapper Carr gone, the JLA sits around and sulks. They miss the little guy!

–REFERENCE: In The Batman Files. Author Matthew Manning, with this item, adorably canonizes a version of his own children’s book, Batman: Two-Face’s Double Take (2010). An escaped Two-Face kidnaps Bruce Wayne, prompting Batgirl and Robin to come to his rescue. Eventually, Batman, Batgirl, and Robin bust Two-Face and his twin henchmen, the Roscetti Brothers.

–FLASHBACK: From Booster Gold Vol. 2 #5. Jim Gordon watches Batgirl in action as she apprehends Scarecrow. Afterward, Batman chats with Jim.

–“The Green Bullet” by John Ostrander/Ken Lashley/Ron Boyd/John Kalisz (JLA 80-Page Giant #1 Part 1) July 1998
Extortionist and blackmailer Andrew “Ferret” Fulton (who Batman knows from his Bat-computer crime-database) is murdered and left with a fake Kryptonite bullet in his pocket in an attempt to falsely connect Superman to the crime. When an eye-witness fingers Superman as the culprit, Batman and Commissioner Gordon investigate. Batman then meets with Superman to question him, confirming what he already knew. The heroes then bust the real murderer, an Intergang crook dressed-up as Superman and wearing a LexCorp jetpack to fly. As usual, the JLA can’t prove that Lex Luthor was linked to the crime, but they threaten Luthor at his Metropolis office, saying he better never pull any stunts in the future.

–FLASHBACK: From Blackest Night #0. In one of their rare calm moments of interaction aboard the JLA satellite HQ, Hal Jordan chats with Batman about how they both witnessed the deaths of their fathers. “No wonder we’re both screwed up,” says Hal, trying to start a friendly conversation with his rival. “Speak for yourself,” mutters a disdainful Bruce. Bruce and Hal have never gotten along, but this is the beginning of an even rockier relationship that the two will have for rest of their lives. Pure hate on the part of Bruce. Good stuff.

–REFERENCE: In Daily Planet: Special Invasion Edition aka Daily Planet Invasion Special #1—originally told in Justice League of America #78. The JLA teams-up with elder cowboy-themed superhero Vigilante (Greg Saunders) to prevent the Doomsters, members of a dying alien race called The Monsan (aka The Monsanians), from terraforming Earth to make it inhabitable for themselves.^[9]

–REFERENCE: In Batman: The Return of Bruce Wayne #5—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #89. The fanatical cultists known as the Hellerites, led by criminal Karl Loftus, return to Gotham for the first time in nearly two hundred years to reclaim the land of their ancestors. Batman teams-up with Phantom Stranger against Loftus and the arisen ghosts of the old Hellerites. Dr. Terence Thirteen also shows up, trying to debunk any validity to the paranormal happenings surrounding Phantom Stranger and the Hellerites. (The anti-occult Dr. Thirteen is like the Scully to Phantom Stranger’s Mulder.)

–REFERENCE: In Identity Crisis #1. Those JLA members that still haven’t revealed their secret IDs to their comrades finally do so, making it a general rule that the JLA will no longer retain ID secrecy amongst themselves moving forward.

–FLASHBACK: From Blackest Night #0. Batman and Hal Jordan argue during a random JLA mission. Bruce and Hal have always hated each other and continue to despise each other. As we’ve said before, things are only gonna get worse between these two as the years dwindle onward.

–REFERENCE: In 52 #30—originally told in Batman #226. Batman has an altercation with security guard Phil Reardon, who suffers a bizarre injury and winds up being able to see only through his fingertips. Reardon becomes the super-villain known as The Ten-Eyed Man and seeks immediate revenge against Batman, who he blames for his condition. Batman defeats the Ten-Eyed Man, putting him behind bars. If you will recall, over a decade ago, before Bruce became a superhero, he trained in the North African desert with the mystical Ten-Eyed Brotherhood (aka “The Ten-Eyed Tribes of the Empty Quarter” aka “The Ghost Tribes of the Ten-Eyed Brotherhood”). As mentioned in Batman #673, Bruce spent six months training with the Ten-Eyed Brotherhood. Superman #710 references Bruce’s training with the Ten-Eyed Brotherhood as well, although it gives a contradictory three month length instead of six. In any case, the question arises: how exactly is Phil Reardon connected to the Brotherhood? Short answer: we are never told. Suffice to say, Reardon must have some connection to the magickical “Ghost Tribes”—maybe he was once in the Brotherhood but lost his memory, and now cosmic fate has returned him to what he once was? Who knows? It’s a mystery for the ages.

–FLASHBACK: From Secret Origins Vol. 2 Annual #3—loosely based on Teen Titans #19 and Teen Titans #25-33. Rough times trouble the Teen Titans as Aqualad quits the team in order to tend to family affairs in Atlantis. Shortly thereafter, Bruce and Dick’s relationship sours when the Teen Titans botch an investigation related to the murder of prominent doctor Arthur Swenson. Batman chews out Robin and influences the JLA to temporarily suspend the Titans, banning them from wearing their costumes! Undeterred, the Titans forge ahead, donning drab grey outfits and becoming a citizen’s patrol under the mentorship of Loren Jupiter. Robin, however, has none of it and quits the team. The Teen Titans—with new members Lilith Clay, Hawk (Hank Hall), Dove (Don Hall), and Herald (Mal Duncan)—eventually solve the case and re-gain the right to wear their true uniforms. Robin then rejoins the team.

–REFERENCE: In Batman Annual #13 Part 1 Intro, The Batman Chronicles #1 Part 1, Batman Chronicles #1 Part 1, Legends of the DC Universe #10-11, Batgirl: Year One #8, and Birds of Prey #89. Batman and Commissioner Gordon discuss Batgirl. While Jim doesn’t say it outright, he acknowledges with a wink and a nod that he knows his daughter is Batgirl. While it’s never explicitly clear when Commissioner Gordon finds out, he definitely finds out pretty early on (i.e. right now). (Commissioner Gordon finding out Batgirl’s secret ID this early is echoed in the quasi-canonical Who’s Who: Update ’87 #1.) Nevertheless, Jim will always treat Babs’ superhero career with a “knowing but not knowing” attitude, purposely pretending not to know. This is very similar to how Jim will engage with Batman’s secret ID, especially based upon implications in “No Man’s Land” for the latter. Even though he knows—he’ll operate with a “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy.

–REFERENCE: In The Batman Files. Batman, Robin, and Batgirl bust an escaped Firefly.

–FLASHBACK: From Nightwing Vol. 2 Annual #2. Dick and Babs go on a secret diner date for burgers and shakes while Batman is away on unspecified JLA business in outer space. Their date has to be kept on the down-low because Robin and Batgirl are supposed to be diligently patrolling the city while Batman is away. This flashback incorrectly says that both Dick and Babs are 16-years-old. In actuality, Babs is three years older than Dick—he’s 15 and she’s 18.^[10] Their date is interrupted by a police call involving Crazy Quilt. Batgirl and Robin go after Crazy Quilt, but the villain traps them in a safe. Batman returns from space, apprehends Crazy Quilt, and saves the teenage heroes. Oh, and Robin gets a boner. Seriously.

–FLASHBACK: From the second feature to Birds of Prey #127. Batman, Robin, and Batgirl take down some random Gotham hoods.

–FLASHBACK: From Booster Gold Vol. 2 #11-12. Booster Gold and his sister Goldstar (Michelle Carter) time-travel from the year 2010 (Bat Year 22) to right now (1996) in order to fix an error on the timestream. What is the error, you ask? Well, the 27th century physicist/thief Wiley Dalbert has been slowly traveling backwards through time with the goal of reaching the “simpler, better times” of the 19th century. Along the way, he has been stealing a ton of loot, so that he will be rich once he reaches his desired era. Cue now: Wiley hires Killer Moth to steal some museum artifacts for him, which Moth does, but Batman, Robin, and Batgirl intervene, resulting in the jailing of Dalbert. This is actually bad news as it turns out because Dalbert’s time-traveling plays a pivotal role in the creation of Batman. Dalbert is supposed to travel to the 19th century and found a hospital, which coincidentally points Dr. Thomas Wayne’s career in a specific direction, which in turn, leads to his death in Crime Alley, which of course, leads to birth of the Dark Knight. Armed with this knowledge, Booster travels back in time (the first time he actually fails to fix the error, knocking out Moth and playing the role of the villain). The second time, however, is a charm. With the confusing backstory out of the way, here is what happens. Booster and Goldstar (from the year 2010) time-travel to now (Year 8), break into the Batcave, and steal the Batmobile. They then steal a Batgirl costume from Barbara Gordon. Booster (dressed as Elvis Presley) and Goldstar (as Batgirl) wind up fighting Killer Moth at the museum, but they make sure that Wiley Dalbert steals the goods and gets away scot-free. This time, Wiley never even crosses paths with Batman. (Thus, Batman won’t actually meet Wiley until Bat Year 15 as Wiley makes his way backward through time.) The Carters then travel back to their correct time, thus re-ensuring that Bruce will become Batman like he was supposed to. Afterward, Alfred tries to explain to the Dynamic Duo that a weird super-villain named “Booster” stole the Batmobile.

–REFERENCE: In The Batman Files. Batman becomes aware of some new developments in the life of Man-Bat (Kirk Langstrom), who has recently begun partnered detective work with private eye Jason Bard. Batman, while keeping tabs on the duo, gets one of Bard’s business cards. The Caped Crusader also learns that Kirk’s wife Francine has begun taking man-bat serum, becoming She-Bat every once in a while. Note that these developments were only canonized in 2011 via The Batman Files. Prior to that, they were solely Silver Age material.

–FLASHBACK: From Birds of Prey #100, the B&W second feature to Batman: Gotham Knights #47, and Detective Comics #600. In a single-panel of Birds of Prey #100, Batman, Robin, and Batgirl swing into action. Since we don’t see where they are headed, we can assume that they are going to battle an escaped Riddler, who terrorizes Gotham with a blimp (as seen in the B&W second feature to Batman: Gotham Knights #47). And since we are lumping flashbacks together, why not include the defeated Riddler, tied-up and strung-up by Batman, as seen in a single-panel in Detective Comics #600.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #561. Batman, Robin, and Batgirl take-out three gun-toting masked criminals on a rooftop.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #682. Batman stops Joker’s scheme to rob the Sea Plane Display in Gotham Bay. Joker has enlisted the aid of Gaggy, Eraser, Penguin, Catwoman (in her new green skintight costume), and a myriad of silly clown thugs to help him.

–REFERENCE: In Trinity #18. Joker yet again escapes jail and hires a brand new gang, consisting of Packy White, Philly Jack Barton, Alby, Charlie “Bigger” Melvin, and Bing Hooley. But when Joker’s heist is ruined by Batman, the Clown Prince of Crime blames the new crew for his defeat. Joker has had the tendency to be all over the place when it comes to caprices and criminal habits in general, but this is the final straw for him. Beginning his descent into the dark side, Joker furiously exclaims that he will murder the five men as revenge. (Joker targeting his own henchmen is the start of a nasty trend that we’ll see much more of this year.) Pop-crime is officially dead. Batman chases after and busts White, Barton, Alby, Melvin, and Hooley, but all five men walk on a technicality, after which they all go into hiding.

–FLASHBACK: From DC Universe Legacies #5. Still on the loose, Joker hires yet another new crew. With his pop-crime phase having officially ended, Joker and his new crew rob the Gotham National Bank, during which Joker kills dozens of hostages, including his own henchmen, out of sheer boredom. (This is a continuation of Joker’s new trend of killing his own henchmen.) Batman arrives seconds too late to save even a single soul. However, Joker is apprehended.

–Batman: Batgirl by Kelley Puckett/Matt Haley (1997)
Our story begins with Babs saying, “I never thought of joining the force…” which is an out-and-out continuity error that contradicts Batgirl: Year One, which shows that Babs desperately tried to join the GCPD, but her dad blocked it from happening. (She also tried to get in the FBI too.) Anyway, onto a synopsis. Batman goes missing, forcing Batgirl to go head-to-head with a yet again escaped Joker for the first time! Unfortunately for Batgirl, Joker’s pop-crime phase is done, meaning he’s become much more deadly. In this vein, Joker captures Batgirl and begins brutally offing his own henchmen. Batman returns and saves the day, but not before taking a bullet to the scalp and slipping into unconsciousness. Batgirl takes down Joker, sending him back behind bars. Batman goes into the care of Dr. Leslie Thompkins. This story is also shown via flashback from DC First: Batgirl/The Joker #1, which gives us the relative timeframe for when this story takes place.

–REFERENCE: In Nightwing Vol. 2 #104 and Batman #600 Part 3. Batman gives Batgirl a new Batbike (aka Batcycle) that has a sidecar. While we won’t see it on our timeline ahead, Batman will often give Batgirl new gear and vehicles. Notably, all of Batgirl’s vehicles will have secret surveillance cameras, which will allow Batman to spy on her.

–“Joker Tips His Hat!” by Ed Brubaker/Stefano Guadiano (Batman #600 Part 3) April 2002
With Batman out of town on unspecified JLA business, Robin and Batgirl are left alone to protect Gotham against a yet again escaped Joker, who has stolen Mad Hatter’s mind-control technology. (Yes, Joker keeps escaping back-to-back-to-back, etc. It simply is what it is.) After riding around in Batgirl’s new Batbike and getting some help from Mad Hatter, Robin and Batgirl confront Joker. The teen heroes not only able sneak in a kiss, but they put Joker behind bars as well!

–REFERENCE: In Justice League #2, Justice League Europe #16, and Justice League Quarterly #3—originally told in Justice League of America #87. The JLA meets the Champions of Angor (aka Justifiers of Angor aka Assemblers of Angor)—Silver Sorceress, Blue Jay, Wandjina the Thunderer, and Jack B Quick.

–REFERENCE: In Justice League: Rise of Arsenal #1 and Justice League: Rise & Fall Special #1 Part 1—originally told in Green Lantern Vol. 2 #85-86 and Teen Titans #44. Batman isn’t a part of this one, but its reverberations are certainly felt across the greater DCU. The Dark Knight is definitely aware of the situation. Due to the recent turbulence, the Teen Titans decide to call it quits. Shortly after the Teen Titans disband, Green Arrow discovers that his fifteen-year-old sidekick Speedy is a heroin user. (Speedy has been doing heroin for a while now, but the loss of the Teen Titans, combined with the fact that Green Arrow has been spending more time with Hal Jordan than him lately, has caused him to spiral out of control.) Speedy goes into rehab and begins a successful recovery, but he will have issues with addiction for the rest of his life.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #682—and referenced in Nightwing Vol. 2 Annual #2 and Batman #683. Originally told in Detective Comics #328 and a few other Silver Age issues, culminating with Batman Family #13-14. While attempting to assist Batman and Robin, Alfred is “killed” by the Tri-State Gang. Bruce and Dick mourn their father figure’s passing at a small funeral. However, Alfred isn’t really dead. Thanks to bizarre circumstances and the meddling of a scientist, Alfred has become the metapowered super-villain known as The Outsider, who plagues Batman and Robin. The Outsider eventually bathes in the scientist’s “regeneration machine” and is restored to his old self, alive and well, although he has no memories of his time spent as the Outsider. The Bat-Family votes not to reveal what has happened to Alfred, feeling that he couldn’t handle the horrible truth—as referenced in Batman #683. When Alfred briefly relapses into the Outsider again, Robin, Batgirl, and Man-Bat team-up to defeat the villain and return Alfred back to safety once again—as referenced in Nightwing Vol. 2 Annual #2. Again, the Bat-Family decides to never tell Alfred about his Outsider alter-ego. (Modern Age canon recognizes the Outsider affair as primarily consisting of: Bruce and Dick mourning Alfred’s death; Batman and Robin defeating the Outsider and restoring Alfred; Robin, Batgirl, and Man-Bat defeating the returning Outsider; and Alfred being restored again. In the Silver Age, Alfred was dead from 1964 to 1966, warring Batman for two full publishing years before it was revealed that he was the Outsider. His brief return as the Outsider against Robin, Batgirl, and Man-Bat occurred in 1977. Contrastingly, in the Modern Age, the whole Outsider affair lasts only a couple days. Technically, Alfred’s relapse could be separate and could go next year, but since the entire Outside affair is greatly compressed as it is, it makes sense to keep it all together here.)

–FLASHBACK: From Nightwing Vol. 2 Annual #2. Following the Alfred/Outsider affair, Dick tells Babs that he loves her, but she pretends that she is sleeping. Meanwhile, Dick’s relationship with Bruce sours even further.

–REFERENCE: In Peacemaker Vol. 2 #1—originally told in Detective Comics #354 and Detective Comics #408. Batman and Robin best Dr. Tzin-Tzin, a deadly agent of the League of Assassins.

–FLASHBACK: From Shadowpact #6—originally told in Detective Comics #410. Batman tracks down a murderer and finds himself at a circus, where he meets several “freaks” including Eddie “Flippy” Deacon, a boy with flippers instead of hands and feet. Batman brings the murderer to justice and saves Flippy’s life.

–REFERENCE: In Batman #692—originally told in Batman #237. Dr. Benjamin Gruener aka The Reaper, a Jewish concentration camp survivor, dresses as the grim reaper and goes on a killing spree. After duking it out with Batman, the Reaper falls off a cliff, supposedly to his death. In actuality, he survives the fall and is cryogenically frozen, so we’ll see him return many years later in Batman #692. Bear in mind, this Reaper is not the Reaper from the “Batman: Year Two” story arc.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #600. Bruce begins dating famous publicist Silver St. Cloud. They fall very much in love, but right from the get-go, Bruce and Silver get into a bad fight (likely due to Bruce’s secret Bat-life getting in the way of his commitment to her). Despite this argument, Bruce and Silver stay together. Silver is arguably, besides Julie Madison or Selina Kyle, Bruce’s first real-deal serious love-affair. Note that Ed Brubaker likely meant for this Batman #600 flashback to signify Silver and Bruce breaking-up at the conclusion of “Strange Apparitions” (which is still to come). However, Brubaker’s Silver flashback occurs specifically in Wayne Manor whereas the Silver/Bruce breakup in “Strange Apparitions” occurs specifically in the Wayne Tower penthouse. Thus, due to this ostensible error, canon is forced to shift this sequence here, making it a scene of Bruce and Silver arguing in Wayne Manor shortly after beginning to date one another.

–FLASHBACK: From the second feature to Countdown to Final Crisis #6—and referenced in JLA/Avengers #3 and JLA Secret Files and Origins #2 Part 2. Originally told in Justice League of America #103. Late October—Halloween weekend. Phantom Stranger tells the heroes that Felix Faust will summon evil spirits, demons, and zombies at a Halloween celebration in Rutland, Vermont. Thus, the team travels to Rutland and, with Phantom Stranger’s assistance, busts Faust and his minions. With the case wrapped, the JLA invites the Phantom Stranger to join the team (!), but he disappears without giving a reply. The JLA records this adventure into its case-files under the name “A Stranger Walks Among Us,” which was the original title of Justice League of America #103, upon which this entry onto our timeline was based. Note that the canonical flashback to this story from the second feature to Countdown to Final Crisis #6, which seemingly must be referencing “A Stranger Walks Among Us,” shows a fairly generic Jesus Saiz-illustrated image that doesn’t actually correspond with any panels from the original Justice League of America #103.

–“Halloween Past: Trick and Defeat” by Art Baltazar/Franco Aureliani/Sergio Carrera (DCU Halloween Special 2009 Part 5) December 2009
October 31—Halloween. This item is also known as DCU Halloween Special ’09 #1 Part 5. As he does every year, Alfred hosts the Annual Wayne Foundation Halloween Charity Ball at Wayne Manor. In a rare occurrence, Bruce actually decides to show up! Bruce chats with Alfred, expressing recent frustrations he’s been having with Dick, who is out trick-or-treating with Babs. (Bruce mentions that Dick is still in high school and still living at Wayne Manor, which helps us place this item just prior to his departure to Hudson University.) Alfred mentions that the Dynamic Duo has possibly been patrolling together too much lately. After Bruce auctions off some of his mother’s dresses, an escaped Killer Moth shows up and tries to rob the party. Commissioner Gordon, who is in attendance at the shindig, mentions that this is the first time Killer Moth has been active since being busted by Batgirl earlier in the year. Killer Moth was indeed jailed by Batgirl earlier this year—actually twice (first by the real Batgirl and then by Goldstar dressed up as Batgirl.) Killer Moth’s Wayne Manor heist is foiled when he answers the door for two trick-or-treaters dressed up as Superman and Batman. After making fun of their costumes, Killer Moth is kayoed by the trick-or-treaters (actually Robin and Batgirl), who save the day.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #600 and 52 #30—and also referenced in The Batman Files. Originally told in Batman #217. Dick (who is 15-years-old now and will turn 16 this coming summer) decides to leave Gotham and move to upstate New York. The reason for the move is because: one, he hasn’t been getting along with Bruce very well; and, two, he has been accepted into an early entry program at Hudson University in upstate New York that will begin with the start of the new semester in January. Dick, like Babs, has a genius-level intellect and will start college at a very young age. Dick gives his Hudson University acceptance letter to Bruce. Someone (presumably Babs, who certainly would be present) snaps a picture of Dick wearing a Hudson University cardigan with Bruce and Alfred in the background. Bruce keeps the picture once it is developed. Shortly thereafter, Dick officially moves to New Carthage, NY. While Dick is living in New York, he will sporadically commute to Gotham to work cases with Batman. Notably, Dick and Babs will continue to be romantically-involved and grow closer in the months to come. Moving forward, it’s likely that Dick and Babs will see each other when he visits Gotham, and it’s also likely that Babs will visit Dick at college.

–REFERENCE: In Underworld Unleashed #1 and The Batman Files—originally told in Detective Comics #358 Part 1 Intro. November. Batman encounters Spellbinder (Delbert Billings), a garishly clad op-art-themed super-villain that has been on a recent robbery spree. Spellbinder evades capture twice by causing Batman to go into a vivid hallucination where the Dark Knight believes he is elsewhere, working another case.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #682—and referenced in Batman #683 and Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight #132. Originally told in Batman #217. Bruce puts Robin’s original costume on display in the Batcave. Afterward, Bruce decides that he and Alfred will move into a penthouse atop the Wayne Enterprises Tower (aka Wayne Foundation Building). In LOTDK #132, writer Archie Goodwin gives us some really profound aperçus into Batman’s psychology behind wanting to leave Wayne Manor. Essentially, he wants to leave the dusty old “museum” behind so he can be centrally located and increase crime-fighting efficiency. Alfred is reluctant to leave stately Wayne Manor and, while we won’t see it listed ahead, Alfred and Bruce will often argue about the move (with Alfred being blunt about wanting to return to the mansion). Nevertheless, Bruce is in charge. As Bruce and Alfred close down the Batcave in preparation for the big move, Alfred shares a fiction story he has written about what the world would be like if Bruce never became Batman. Upon moving into the Wayne Tower penthouse, Batman and Alfred (with metahuman assistance) build an underground bunker with multiple secret exits, entrances, and elevators deep beneath the building. This “Bat-Bunker” will become Batman’s new main base of operations. All set up in the Bat-Bunker, Batman and Alfred set up and begin enacting brand new routines for downtown life. (As the “penthouse era” starts, so signals the end of the Silver Age and the beginning of the Bronze Age. For the purposes of this chronology, this Bronze Age, or “Modern Bronze Age,” will comprise the rest of the “Early Period.”)

–REFERENCE: In The Batman Files. Batman installs a JLA teleporter in the Bat-Bunker.

–REFERENCE: In Batman #402 and Batman Incorporated #6—originally told in Batman #217. Bruce initiates the Wayne Enterprises-funded “Victims Incorporated Program.” Victims Inc functions as a service which provides assistance to those who have lost loved ones at the hands of Gotham crime. The program also solves cold murder cases that the GCPD has been unable to crack. Victims Inc, however, is short-lived due to the dangerous exposure it places upon Wayne Enterprises, on both Bruce and his employees.

–REFERENCE: In Infinity Inc #39 and Starman Vol. 2 #17—originally told in Justice League of America #91-92. A menacing alien boy (A-Rym) and his pet beast Teppy rampage on Earth, befriending Solomon Grundy in the process. Outside of Gotham City, the JSA, JLA (sans Batman, Green Arrow, and Aquaman), and Robin team up to defeat A-Rym, Teppy, and Grundy. Meanwhile, in New England, Batman, Green Arrow, Aquaman, and Deadman work a separate case, handling a League of Assassins killer named M’naku.

–FLASHBACK: From Justice League of America Vol. 2 #29—and referenced in Justice League America #62-65. Originally told in Justice League of America #96-98. The JLA fights the cosmic vampire known as Starbreaker, an evil super-villain and member of the alien Sun-Eater species. They defeat Starbreaker and his robotic hench-insects (called Mechanix), stopping them from plunging the Earth into the sun.

–REFERENCE: In Daily Planet: Special Invasion Edition aka Daily Planet Invasion Special #1—originally told in Justice League of America #99. The benevolent aliens Bür Sëd and Kēr Sēd try to help Earth by planting eco-friendly seeds across the planet. However, when invasive plant growth spreads across the globe, the JLA is forced to intervene, fighting the adamant Bür Sëd and Kēr Sēd. Eventually, the aliens realize the error of their ways, clean up the invasive growth, and return to their home planet.

–FLASHBACK: From Stars & STRIPE #9 and Justice League of America Vol. 2 #0—and referenced in Justice League of America Vol. 2 #0, Stars & STRIPE #0, and Seven Soldiers of Victory #1. Originally told in Justice League of America #100-102. When The Iron Hand threatens all life on the planet, the JLA and JSA are on the case. Meanwhile, following a fight against Nebula Man, the original Seven Soldiers of Victory (aka Law’s Legionnaires)—Crimson Avenger, Shining Knight (Sir Justin Arthur) and his flying horse Victory, Star-Spangled Kid (Sylvester Pemberton), Vigilante (Greg Saunders), Stuff (aka The Chinatown Kid), Stripesy (Pat Dugan), and Wing How—each get blasted into different time periods (from their correct time of 1948). After summoning and consulting with the cosmic being known as Aurakles (aka Oracle), the JSA and JLA mix lineups and travel to each time period to perform rescues. Batman—pictured wearing the wrong costume—teams with Hourman (Rex Tyler) and Starman (Ted Knight) to rescue Stripesy from Ancient Egypt (as seen via flashback from Stars & STRIPE #9 and referenced in Stars & STRIPE #0). Unfortunately, after being rescued, the majority of the Seven Soldiers cannot return back to 1948 and stay in the present. The JLA, JSA, and Seven Soldiers of Victory then conduct a triple-group-team-up to defeat the Iron Hand, whose power merges with Nebula Man’s. The villains are defeated, but Red Tornado becomes the first major member of the superhero community to die, sacrificing himself to save the Earth. With the mission wrapped, Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman mourn Red Tornado’s passing (as seen through flashback in Justice League of America Vol. 2 #0). PS. Red Tornado is quickly resurrected shortly thereafter. Don’t forget, Red Tornado is technically an Air Elemental (aka Wind Elemental) housed inside an android body. Whenever he dies, he can be rebuilt and return to life when the Elemental returns. Tornado will die several more times over the course of the next decade, including during The Crisis on Infinite Earths. No big deal.

–FLASHBACK: From Detective Comics #0, Batman: Bane of the Demon #2, Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 #2, the second feature to Countdown to Final Crisis #4, Batman #561, and Batman #683—originally told in “The Saga of Ra’s al Ghul” by Denny O’Neil/Neal Adams (Detective Comics #411, Batman #232, Batman #235, Batman #240, and Batman #242-245), published in 1971-1972. Every single panel of every page of this Bronze Age classic can be read as-is and considered in-continuity for the Modern Age (except for Batman #242). The tale is also referenced constantly in Modern Age continuity, so its major elements are definitively canon. Plus, Batman is depicted wearing his correct yellow oval costume in the Batman Incorporated Absolute Edition, officially making Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 canon in both the Modern Age and New 52. In “The Saga of Ra’s al Ghul,” the treacherous League of Assassins has reared its mysterious head. Batman’s investigations into the secret criminal empire take him to the Far East where he battles with one of the League’s top operatives, Dr. Ebeneezer Darrk. It is during this confrontation that Bruce first meets the woman who will mother his child, Talia al Ghul.^[11][12] After returning to the States, Batman learns that Robin has been kidnapped from Hudson University. When a Batcave alarm is tripped, the Caped Crusader departs from his Bat-Bunker and frantically swings over to the currently unused Batcave. There, Batman finds Talia’s father and leader of the League of Assassins, Ra’s al Ghul, waiting for him. Ra’s al Ghul knows his secret identity! (Ra’s is accompanied by a very disrespectful member of the Ubu tribe, a cult of warriors loyal to the death to the League of Assassins.) Ra’s then informs Bruce that Talia has also been kidnapped. Reluctantly, Bruce teams-up with Ra’s and they head out across the globe—to India and the Himalayas—in search of the missing persons. Batman deals with numerous deadly situations and eventually finds Robin. (A flashback from the second feature to Countdown to Final Crisis #4 adds a scene to Batman #232 that was not in the original issue. It shows Batman and Ra’s al Ghul sword-fighting in the League of Assassins’ Himalayan compound as Talia, Ubu, and a bound Robin watch with excited interest.) Turns out Ra’s and Talia set up Batman, but he knew the whole time and played along anyway. But why did they set him up? Because Ra’s wanted to make sure that Batman was a worthy successor to lead the League and to wed his smitten daughter, of course. Not long after their first encounter, Batman meets Talia yet again after she attempts to execute a traitor to the League of Assassins in Louisiana. The third meeting between Talia and Batman comes, again, shortly thereafter when a prominent US Army scientist is murdered and his brain is removed from his skull. Ra’s has a vested interest in the case, so he sends his daughter to team-up with Batman on the investigation. Together, they catch the murderer, but Batman learns that Ra’s had cut out the man’s brain in order to learn the government secrets hidden within. There’s a lot of weird sci-fi stuff going on here with a re-animated talking brain, sodium pentathol, reverse-sodium pentathol, and more. Maybe Bruce was having a Joker Toxin/Scarecrow Gas related freak-out while this escapade was going on. Although, we do meet the head scientist of the League of Assassins, Dr. Moon, and whenever he makes an appearance, strange things always occur. In this instance, for example, Dr. Moon briefly re-animates the brain of deceased scientist Dr. Mason Sterling. The following final arc of “The Saga of Ra’s al Ghul” is the most famous. However, issue #242 includes some totally incorrect Matches Malone stuff. Malone’s anachronistic re-appearance and death are both totally wrong and couldn’t have happened. For these reasons the events of this single issue are definitively non-canon, so if you read this storyline either skip issue #242 or disregard the Malone parts.^[13] Anyway, our classic tale continues in issue #243 with Batman assembling a team consisting of scientist Dr. Harris Blaine, champion skier Molly Post, and ex-League of Assassins hitman Lo Ling to help him hunt down Ra’s. In order to free up some time on his schedule, Bruce fakes his own death (plane crash in South America). After finally tracking Ra’s al Ghul down, Batman learns the secret of the Demon’s Head: the Lazarus Pits have been keeping him alive for hundreds of years! A shirtless Batman and Ra’s al Ghul epically sword-duel each other in the desert as Talia looks on. (This sword fight is also shown via flashback from Batman #561 and Batman #683.) The “Saga of Ra’s al Ghul” ends with a wrap-up issue (#245) where Batman solves a case involving two gangsters that are backing rival corrupt mayoral candidates. After closing the investigation, Batman jets down to South America where he is “miraculously discovered” wandering in the South American jungle—thus “reviving” Bruce Wayne from his faked plane crash death.

–REFERENCE: In Robin Vol. 2 #1—originally told in Detective Comics #428. Batman teams up with GCPD Detective Steven “Shotgun” Smith to bring down some drug dealers.

–REFERENCE: In Underworld Unleashed #1 and The Batman Files—originally told in Detective Comics #358 Part 1 Conclusion. Late November. When Spellbinder tries his hallucination tricks on Batman for a third time, the Dark Knight is in total control and easily takes him down.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #561. Late November. As he does every year, Batman visits Crime Alley to honor his mother and father on the anniversary of their deaths.

–FLASHBACK: From the second feature to Detective Comics #782. Late November. Continuing from the previous flashback, Batman places two fresh roses on Crime Alley to commemorate the anniversary of his parents’ deaths.

–NOTE: In a flashback from JLA 80-Page Giant #1 Part 2. Batman isn’t involved in this item, but he would be well aware of it as a JLA member. The team foolishly accepts a one billion dollar donation from the underhanded Tulane Bryce. Green Arrow realizes this was a big PR mistake. Never accept money unless you know it’s clean, heroes!

–REFERENCE: In Legends of the DC Universe #12-13—originally told in the Green Lantern/Green Arrow second feature from Flash #218. Green Arrow accidentally kills someone. Distraught over his actions, Green Arrow aimlessly flies the Arrowjet, crashing into a snowy mountain range. Having just barely survived, Green Arrow decides to make a big change. In an attempt to find inner peace, Green Arrow leaves the JLA and becomes a Buddhist monk. He shaves his head and moves into an ashram under the tutelage of Master Jensen.

–FLASHBACK: From the second feature to 52 #13, Secret Origins Vol. 2 #30, and Identity Crisis #1—and referenced in Secret Origins Vol. 2 #30. Originally told in Justice League of America #105. Elongated Man joins the Justice League of America. On his first case with the JLA, the team defeats the Putty Men (villains linked to Queen Bee Zazzala). The original story from Justice League of America #105 does not feature Batman. However, the Modern Age retcon flashback inserts the Dark Knight, hence the inclusion of the “Case of the Putty Men” on our timeline. After the case wraps, Sue Dibny hangs out with the JLA. Notably, as mentioned above, Elongated Man originally joined the JLA well before Zatanna and Firestorm in the Silver/Bronze Age, but JLA Incarnations #3 seems to have radically restructured the Modern Age by placing Zatanna and Firestorm’s inclusion on the JLA prior to the inclusion of Elongated Man.

–FLASHBACK: From the second feature to 52 #38—and referenced in Stars & STRIPE #9, Stars & STRIPE #0, Justice League of America Vol. 2 #0. Originally told in Justice League of America #106. Red Tornado officially joins the JLA. Bruce helps him come up with the secret identity of “John Smith.” Notably, as mentioned above, Elongated Man and Red Tornado originally joined the JLA well before Zatanna and Firestorm in the Silver/Bronze Age, but JLA Incarnations #3 seems to have radically restructured the Modern Age by placing Zatanna and Firestorm’s inclusion on the JLA prior to the inclusion of Elongated Man and Red Tornado.

–REFERENCE: In Justice League of America Annual #3 and Justice League of America Vol. 2 #1. Red Tornado begins dating Kathy Sutton and introduces her to his JLA teammates.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #683 and Trinity #18—originally told in Batman #251. Joker finally catches up with his old crew (Packy White, Philly Jack Barton, Alby, Charlie “Bigger” Melvin, and Bing Hooley), against whom he’s sworn murderous revenge for having failed him earlier this year. Thus, Batman is forced to deal with Joker’s “Five Way Revenge” scheme. Joker is able to murder four of his ex-cronies, including White, Barton, Alby, and Melvin. Batman rescues a wheelchair-bound Hooley (Joker’s fifth ex-henchman) from a shark tank death trap before busting the Clown Prince of Crime.

–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #601-603—originally told in The Brave and The Bold #109. The zombie of 19th century gangster Jack Dobbs attacks Gotham ad man Harry Matthews, who is a close pal of occultist Jason Blood, who just happens to be the immortal human host vessel for the demon Etrigan! Blood cuts short a rendezvous with his friend Glenda Mark to turn into Etrigan and save Matthews. Eventually, Batman teams-up with Etrigan and Blood’s other friend Randu Singh to exorcize Dobbs.

–FLASHBACK: From Batman #614. Batman patrols with Batgirl.

–FLASHBACK: From Christmas With the Super-Heroes #2. Christmas. Batman and Robin respond to an alert on their “crime computer,” solve the case, and return home in time to celebrate the holiday with Alfred.

–REFERENCE: In Batman Secret Files and Origins #1 Part 3—originally told in Detective Comics #437. Batman involves himself in “The Case of Matuchima,” in which several men don the Mask of Matuchima, the death god of the Xochipecs. The mask injects them with a drug that gives them super-human fighting ability. This leads to a chain of death and mayhem that ends with the person that started it all fatally jumping off a loge and crashing through the giant replica of the mask, destroying both it and the real mask. Afterward, Batman repairs the giant replica of the Mask of Matuchima to keep as a trophy in the Bat-Bunker.

–FLASHBACK: From Wizard #0 Special: Hush Interlude. Batman fights an escaped Joker, who permanently scars his back with a large hook.

–“Night of the Bat” by Len Wein/Bernie Wrightson (Swamp Thing #7/Batman Hidden Treasures #1 Part 2) December 1973 / December 2010
Originally told in 1973’s Swamp Thing #7, this tale was first brought into continuity for the Modern Age via a reference in Swamp Thing Vol. 2 #52-55. Its re-publication in December 2010 lends credence to the idea that its entire story should be Modern Age canon in full, especially since it has a lot of connective tissue to other Modern Age concepts. Onto a synopsis! Scientist Alec Holland has recently been turned into Swamp Thing! (More correctly, Alec Holland was killed, after which a Plant Elemental was born with Holland’s memories and personality implanted in its mind. All Plant Elementals are members of the Parliament of Trees, a group sworn to protect the Green, the mystic force that binds all vegetal life together.) Together with his pet dog Mutt, Swamp Thing makes his first trip to Gotham City in an attempt to track down Mr. E (leader of the Conclave), who is responsible for his horrific transformation. Not only that, Mr. E has also kidnapped his friends—Abigail Arcane and Interpol agent Matthew Cable. (Abby will later marry Matthew and then marry Swamp Thing. Matthew will later die and become Morpheus’ raven in the Dreaming.) Notably, a new Chief O’Hara makes an appearance. This must be the original O’Hara’s younger relative (also seen in Batman #700 as “Officer O’Hara”), who has now been promoted. Batman, who has been tracking Mr. E and the Conclave for months now, has his first clash with Swamp Thing, who has not yet re-mastered the powers of speech. Eventually, Batman is present when Swamp Thing saves his Abigail and Matthew. In the process, Wayne Foundation executive Nathan Ellery is outed as the leader of the Conclave. Ellery kills poor Mutt but then falls off a rooftop balcony, leaving him permanently paralyzed from the waist down.

_______________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________

<<< PREVIOUS: YEAR SEVEN <<< | >>> NEXT: YEAR NINE >>>

1. ^[1]COLLIN COLSHER: Batgirl’s public debut is upon us. The overall canonicity of Batgirl: Year One (2003) is debatable, with most of the issues containing continuity errors (depending on your point of view). It’s up to you whether you include it in your personal headcanon, as the series can definitely go either way, especially depending on the individual issue. Keep in mind that Batgirl: Year One is the only Modern Age Batgirl debut story that isn’t coming from a flashback or reference, so it holds significant weight. In any case, several comics flashback-to and/or reference Batgirl’s debut, some of them nodding toward Batgirl: Year One while others hint at her original origin from the Silver Age’s Detective Comics #359, which has already been partly listed on our chronology above. In the former instances (Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 and Birds of Prey #127), Batgirl fights Killer Moth and saves Bruce, who is en route to a masquerade ball. In the latter instances (Batgirl: Year One, Batman: Batgirl, and The Batman Files), Batgirl fights Killer Moth and saves Bruce at the masquerade ball. And yet another set of instances (Batgirl: Year One, Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20, and DC First: Batgirl/Joker #1) shows a continuation featuring Batgirl fighting and finally defeating Killer Moth in the woods outside the masquerade ball. What this tells us is that Batgirl completes these three actions in the above-listed sequence. This does require some creative reader interpretation as things don’t exactly jibe and there are some (as mentioned above) continuity errors that must be addressed. The path of least resistance is to simply disregard the first three issues of Batgirl: Year One, which solves almost all problems. However, to reiterate once again, Batgirl: Year One is the only Modern Age Batgirl debut story that isn’t coming from a flashback or reference. Because of this, I’ve chosen to include it in-full with all necessary caveats. Bear in mind, no matter your personal headcanon, there are multiple legitimate paths forward for Batgirl, some of which are very contradictory, but all of which requiring certain fanwanks. Modern Age Batgirl is messy, maybe one of the most messy characters to deal with, that’s just how it is.↩
2. ^[2]COLLIN COLSHER: Scott Beatty and Chuck Dixon wrote 2003’s Batgirl: Year One with two “official” DC timelines—from the Zero Hour #0 (1994) and Secret Files & Origins Guide to the DCU 2000 (2000)—in mind. Both of these timelines diverge from the Silver Age version of Batgirl’s origin, pushing her debut later, in line with a satellite-based JLA and Deadman’s debut. (Essentially, this pushed Batgirl’s debut from being linked to 1967-related stories to being linked to 1970-related stories.) Beatty and Dixon’s narrative makes references to the Teen Titans, JL Satellite, Rupert Thorne, Deadman, the League of Assassins, and more. But curiously, it tries to stamp a contradictory earlier setting onto its narrative as well. Jim Gordon isn’t yet commissioner and Batman wears an older costume (through most of it). The JL Satellite is a tough addition to the narrative, but it really can’t be ignored. (Batgirl originally debuted in 1967, three years before the JL Satellite debut, and any Modern Age timeline that tries to force the satellite prior to Batgirl’s debut just doesn’t work. Based upon the Batgirl: Year One narrative, the JL Satellite debut must occur in-between issues #5 and #6.) Originally, I tried to keep Batgirl: Year One earlier, while marking the first few issues (containing Year 7-ish stuff) as canon, and relegating the final few issues (containing Year 8-ish stuff) as non-canon. Other chronologists, such as Chris J Miller and Frank Fernandez, try to solve Batgirl: Year One‘s problems by fanwanking big ellipses in the middle of the series, thus effectively keeping the first few issues separated from the last few issues. Chris J Miller goes so far as to insert a whopping two-year-long ellipsis! It’s not ideal to have parts of a series canon, while other parts are not. Nor is ideal to create long ellipses when the narrative clearly doesn’t warrant gaps. However, it’s obvious that there is indeed some sort of deliberate (and legitimate) two-month-long ellipsis between Batgirl: Year One #4 and Batgirl: Year One #5. The best route, and the one we’ve taken, is to canonize the whole Batgirl: Year One series, including this monthlong ellipsis, while notating error/caveat notations where necessary.

   One of the goals of my Modern Age timeline is to mirror the Silver/Bronze Age as much as possible. However, the Modern Age is decidedly different, and this can’t always be done. Such is the case with Batgirl, specifically. There is a possible reordering of Year 8 that very closely mirrors the Silver Age chronologically (stories from 1967 through 1973), but it wouldn’t be possible without a rather huge (too huge) ellipsis between issues #4 and #5. Due to this particular problem, adhering to the Silver Age order to the letter isn’t feasible. Early Modern Age Batgirl origins—like Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20, which does perfectly mirror Silver Age history—must therefore be disregarded to some extent. Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 still contains canonical material, but it cannot be regarded as gospel, especially in the face of Batgirl: Year One.

   MILO NOUSIAINEN: Batgirl: Year One has a lot of misplaced fanservice, but it’s a fine exploration of Barbara Gordon’s early days, and the art is great. Things like the JL satellite and Batman dealing with the League of Assassins and Deadman seem to be deliberate choices by Scott Beatty and Chuck Dixon, not mistakes, but they wind up coming off more like Easter eggs (especially the inclusion of the satellite, which serves no narrative purpose in the story other than defining the era in which the story takes place). It’s clear that Beatty and Dixon have written Batgirl: Year One to occur in Year 8. Evidence of this can be found with Barbara noting that Robin has grown a few inches since they last met at the end of Robin: Year One. They both also look taller and older in the main story of Batgirl: Year One than they do in the flashback to Robin: Year One. This speaks to a gap between the tales, which pushes Batgirl: Year One into Year 8. Since Wayne Manor and the Batcave are central to Batgirl: Year One‘s narrative, it must go prior to Bruce’s move into the penthouse, but after the debut of the Teen Titans, and after/overlapping with the Deadman adventure in Nanda Parbat. Also, Barbara ripping up an “Elect Rupert Thorne” poster makes sense since the events of “Strange Apparitions” are looming. This also leaves room for Bat-Woman, Bat-Girl, and Ace the Bat-Hound to debut before Batgirl: Year One (mirroring the Silver Age), by which time they could be retired and somewhat forgotten. In Batgirl: Year One, there are many references to Batgirl being the third member of the Bat-Family (fourth if you include Alfred). There is also a funny series of lines where Jim Gordon asks if Batman is “expanding the franchise,” to which Robin replies, “And have to worry about a Batwoman or Bat-Hound bogarting the trademark?” In Batgirl: Year One, Alfred also says, “We’re going to need a bigger cave.” Killer Moth delivers “Now there’s three of them!” commentary. And upon her own debut, Batgirl laments having not decided to call herself Batwoman. All of this implies that Bat-Woman has already retired. Robin’s “bogarting the trademark” line functions as a callback—not a weird meta reference to their impending debuts. However, even with the correct placement of Batgirl: Year One here, errors still persist—such as the wrong Bat-costume and Gordon not yet being commissioner.

   PURPLEGLOVEZ (TIPTUP JR 94): A few observations regarding Batgirl’s origin in the Modern Age. First, Batgirl: Year One is the definitive Batgirl origin story, and it goes here in Year 8. As such, like the Batman Chronology Project, I disagree with Chris J Miller’s placement of a two year ellipsis within Batgirl: Year One. Realistically, there is no place for any lengthy continuity gap. A month is the absolute maximum about of time that could pass between issue #4 and #5, and even that is pushing it. Second, touching Kathy Kane and Bette Kane, keep in mind that Batgirl: Year One was written at a time when they were not canon. (Their only reference would have been a photo in The Killing Joke—hardly official, especially back then.) Batman #682 and Batman Incorporated #4 have Robin mentioning he doesn’t trust that “bogus Batgirl” or something to that effect, but it would be very strange if he was talking about Barbara there. You could take this to mean Betty and Babs were around at the same time, but the overwhelming implication from Grant Morrison is that Bette as Bat-Girl precedes Babs as Batgirl by years (which also correctly mirrors the original timelines of the Golden Age and Silver Age). Third, while writing Batgirl: Year One, creators Chuck Dixon and Scott Beatty clearly used the Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 model where Babs gets her masters before starting at the library, Two-Face was around when she was 13-years-old, and she starts college at 16-years-old. In my opinion, the idea of her getting a master’s degree in two years, even with her advanced schooling, is ludicrous. Plus, there are post-Batgirl: Year One stories that plainly place her in college after debuting as Batgirl, and intimate that she was around 18-years-old (or just turning 18) the year of her debut. (There are workarounds for these things, which the Batman Chronology Project has taken, but they are messy.) In regard to the JL Satellite appearance in Batgirl: Year One #6-7, Dixon and Beatty (as mentioned by Collin above) screwed up by using the flimsy timeline from Secret Files & Origins Guide to the DCU 2000 as a guide, which has the satellite erroneously coming before Batgirl. It’s likely that they intended to follow that path, thinking of the satellite coming before Batgirl, but of course what we get instead is the debut of the satellite forced dab smack into the middle of their arc.

   FRANK FERNANDEZ: My Batgirl headcanon fully mirrors the Silver/Bronze Age, but in order to do so, it requires a unique timeline perspective, and unique caveats as well. Before addressing the differences, we can agree that a short (and necessary) ellipsis—of only two months, not two years—exists in-between Batgirl: Year One issues #4 and #5. A Modern Age Batgirl timeline that “perfectly” mirrors the Silver/Bronze Age is not only achievable, it is also based upon completely plausible postulates that are equal to what the Real Batman Chronology Project posits here. Unfortunately, going my route warrants a bit of divergence from Modern sensibility that many, aside from Chris J Miller and myself, are not willing to make. The first point of divergence is that regard for Secret Origins Vol. 2 #20 would have to be at a gospel level, almost trumping the canonicity of Batgirl: Year One. Secondly, in issue #7, the reference to Batman adventuring in Tibet with Deadman would have to be a wholly novel adventure, as it could no longer connect to The Brave and The Bold #79 and Strange Adventures #214-216. Thirdly, the durations of Babs’ various collegiate schoolings and congressional run would have to be squeezed even more than they already are (and slid even earlier).↩

3. ^[3]COLLIN COLSHER: The Silver Age series, done mainly as a fun tribute to the Silver Age era of comics, is canon thanks to a reference in the “Tower of Babel” arc, specifically in JLA #46. The Silver Age series is notable because it will end with the start of the four-part “mind-wipe scandal.” Once exposed, the scandal will eventually rock the superhero community to its core. We know Silver Age begins here because it’s post-Batgirl and pre-satellite and Green Arrow is totally clean-shaven (pre-goatee), among other minor reasons. The editorial idea behind Silver Age, at its time of publication, was that it would play fast-and-loose with continuity, giving creators room to throw in Easter Eggs and coltish anachronisms aplenty. Therefore, the series does contain more than a few big flubs. We’ll highlight these errors as they arise within the synopses below.↩
4. ^[4]COLLIN COLSHER: JLA Incarnations #2 contains a lot of errors, which I will  address as we come to them. Don’t forget, scholar Mike Kooiman questions the canonicity of JLA Incarnations #2, citing that it is “a post-Crisis tale of Superman’s joining the League and probably did not happen in post-Infinite Crisis continuity.” Chris J Miller echoes this, adding that JLA Incarnations #2 was “originally written to clarify when and how Batman joined the League (and Superman didn’t) in post-Crisis canon. Those aspects are now moot [due to Infinite Crisis retcons], but the events may still have occurred in some fashion.” In terms of reasoning for placement here, JL Incarnations #2 shows Green Arrow just starting to grow out his facial hair for the first time (getting ready for his goatee look). Personally, I think this issue should be summarily ignored as well, but I’ve included it for the sake of completeness (and because countless folks have messaged me in its defense over the years).↩
5. ^[5]PURPLEGLOVEZ (TIPTUP JR 94): A few quick continuity error notes about JLA Classified #50-54. First, Batman makes an odd comment that Robin has “recently set out on his own.” This is problematic because the JLA is still in Happy Harbor, meaning it should be way too early for the many retconned schisms between Bruce and Dick to take place. Second, the story notes that Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman (“not an active member”) had been shirking League duty prior to this. At story’s end, the Trinity resolve to start attending regular meetings. This is an error because, at this point, the Trinity would already have been involved quite a bit with the team. Third, the Atom merely reads the files on Titus after the fact; his absence is unexplained, but he certainly would have been a JLA member at this point.↩
6. ^[6]COLLIN COLSHER: The JLA team listed on the title page of JLA Incarnations #3 features only the characters that appear in the issue. Also, Batman and Superman are not reserve members. They are full-time. The current thirteen-person JLA lineup features Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, Black Canary, Aquaman, Hal Jordan, Flash, Martian Manhunter, Green Arrow, Hawkman, the Atom, Zatanna, and Firestorm. Bear in mind, in the Silver Age, Zatanna and Firestorm originally joined the JLA long after the team had started using the satellite. This is obviously not the case in the very different Modern Age, and JLA Incarnations #3 stamps that in hard. Because of JLA Incarnations #3, the order of characters joining the JLA is seemingly changed from Elongated Man, Red Tornado, Zatanna, then Firestorm to Zatanna, Firestorm, Elongated Man, then Red Tornado. There is an alternate route we could take that keeps the original Silver/Bronze Age order of when characters joined the JLA, but that would force us to abandon the original Silver/Bronze Age order of stories. Pick your poison. I’ve gone with the radically revamped order of when characters joined the JLA.↩
7. ^[7]COLLIN COLSHER: The Justice League has just launched its new satellite HQ, which will be seen in use in Batgirl: Year One #6-7. Don’t forget there has been a two-month-long ellipsis between Batgirl: Year One #4 and Batgirl: Year One #5. Batman doesn’t appear in Batgirl: Year One #5, hence why we’ve skipped that issue and gone straight to issue #6. Though, note that issues #5-6 contain some big continuity errors. First, Jim Gordon is still a captain. Second, it includes a totally incorrect version of Garfield Lynn’s debut as Firefly. Third, Batman is wearing the wrong costume.↩
8. ^[8]COLLIN COLSHER: Originally, in the Silver Age, Deadman’s first interaction with Batman took place in Gotham, and dealt with local syndicate killers (including Joe Chill’s brother!) that were loosely connected to Hook and the League of Assassins. But thanks to Batgirl: Year One #7, the first Batman/Deadman team-up in the Modern Age gets moved to Tibet and directly involves the Sensei and the League of Assassins. Notably, Batman and Deadman will again travel to Tibet to challenge the Sensei and the League of Assassins in Deadman Vol. 2 #1, but this won’t happen for a couple years (despite the fact that Deadman Vol. 2 #1 incorrectly places itself mere months after Deadman’s debut). It’s possible that author Scott Beatty was trying to reference Deadman Vol. 2 #1 in Batgirl: Year One #7, but it’s just not possible because Cleveland Brand dies in Deadman Vol. 2 #1, and we’ll see him alive and well in coming years.↩
9. ^[9]COLLIN COLSHER / SHADZ: Daily Planet: Special Invasion Edition references a couple other alien encounters. The first reference makes mention of lizard creatures trying to eat all humans, forcing underground human militias to defeat them. This is a cheeky nod to the TV show V for which DC published a tie-in comic in 1985-1986. Despite this Easter egg, V cannot be canon on the primary DCU timeline, although we can imagine some mini version of it happening. And the second reference tells us that aliens capture Superman, Hawkman, Martian Manhunter, and Starfire before being easily defeated. This event obviously goes later, after Starfire’s debut. Since there is no guarantee of Batman being involved in either of these references, they are staying off the timeline.↩
10. ^[10]COLLIN COLSHER: Originally, Babs was always about three years older than Dick (in the Silver/Bronze Age and throughout most of the Modern Age). This was the case for decades until Nightwing Vol. 2 Annual #2 (2007) retconned Babs and Dick’s ages to be exactly the same. However, I have disregarded this rather late and unnecessary retcon because it really muddles things up and contradicts decades worth of continuity for no real narrative reason. “Folie à deux” by Kelley Puckett/Terry Dodson (from 1998′s Legends of the DC Universe #10-11), which overlaps with Batgirl: Year One, also tells us that Babs turns 18-years-old shortly after debuting as Batgirl.↩
11. ^[11]COLLIN COLSHER: Talia is the daughter of Ra’s al Ghul, leader of the League of Assassins. According to her Arabic familial history (and creator Denny O’Neil’s intention), Talia does not have a last name. However, the Westernized version of her full name, while incorrect in Arabic, is “Talia al Ghul.” Since cultural lexicon basically trumps O’Neil’s original intention, especially in the Modern Age, the use of “Talia al Ghūl” (with surname) is basically acceptable grammar even though it’s technically wrong. Some might fight you on that, but I certainly don’t have the energy to engage in that debate.↩
12. ^[12]COLLIN COLSHER: How old is Talia when she meets Batman? As per the original comics and Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 #2, she clearly looks to be in her late teenage years and is old enough to attend university. However, Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 #2 tells us that Ra’s al Ghul meets Talia’s mom (and impregnates her) either at or shortly after the Live Aid concert in 1985. This works just fine for the New 52 timeline, under which Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 #2 was published (and, in fact, this was writer Grant Morrison’s way of contemporizing Denny O’Neil’s Talia origin story from Birth of the Demon, which originally revealed that Talia was conceived during Woodstock in 1969). However, for the Modern Age, which Batman Incorporated Vol. 2 #2 is supposed to be canon in as well, connecting Talia’s origin to the Live Aid concert makes things complicated, as Talia would only be around 11 or 12-years old right now. So either the concert references are bogus or we must assume that the League of Assassins has done to Talia what will be done to Damian and Damian’s clones: rapid sci-fi aging. No matter the situation or how many years Talia has existed in the world, she’s in the range of 18 to 21-years-old when she meets the Dark Knight in the Modern Age—likely closer to the former. Therefore, we should likely ignore any references to Woodstock or Live Aid. Maybe Ra’s al Ghul and Melisande hooked up at the 1976 Queen concert in Hyde Park.↩
13. ^[13]COLLIN COLSHER: Batman #242 is non-canon because it contradicts Brian K Vaughan’s Batman #589, in which we learn that Batman encountered Matches Malone very early in his career (before Robin and while Harvey Dent was still ADA). We also learn that Matches fakes his death around this time and skips town, not returning to Gotham for over a decade (actually seventeen years by my calculations). Of course, all of this contradicts Malone’s appearance and death in Batman #242. Not to mention, Batman uses the Matches Malone disguise in storylines from Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight #89-90, Batman Confidential #22-25, and Superman/Batman #85-87 (all of which take place before “The Saga of Ra’s al Ghul”).↩