Rebirth Year Nineteen (Part 1)

(January 2020 to June 2020)

–Batman and The Outsiders Vol. 3 #9-12

As seen in the giant continuity error that is the Batman-less epilogue to Batman and The Outsiders Vol. 3 #8 (which actually goes right here despite all appearances within the comic itself), Ra’s al Ghul orders Ishmael to violently murder Tina McClintock, a teacher that works at Jefferson’s school in Metropolis. Ra’s al Ghul also has the school bombed. Batman immediately investigates and then visits Jefferson to offer him half-hearted condolences. Understandably, neither Batman nor Katana are able to calm the storm raging within Jefferson. However, Meanwhile, Jefferson and Tatsu meet up later and form a tighter bond, vowing to support each other as best they can. Later, Batman takes Orphan and Signal on a field test, watching them patrol in Metropolis. Afterward, Cassie and Duke finally tell Bruce that Shiva is back, and he scolds them for keeping it a secret. Superman shows up to chat with Bruce, offering condolences about Alfred and warning him to slow his roll in regard to how he handles the Outsiders and the Ra’s al Ghul situation at hand. Bruce scoffs at Superman’s advice, chastising the Man of Steel for having revealed his secret ID to the world. While Bruce and Superman argue, Cassie and Duke vow to support each other as best they can. Later, Shiva approaches Jefferson saying that, together, they can and should kill Ra’s al Ghul. A day later, back in Gotham, Batman meets with Sofia. Then, as Bruce, he meets with Elfa, learning more about Kaliber’s connection to the Markovian Black Market, specifically to arms dealer Martina Dimentieva. Elfa tells Bruce that Dimentieva has an alien doomsday weapon. Bruce knows that Ra’s al Ghul now has the weapon. In Cambodia, Black Lightning and Shiva chase after Dimentieva in an effort to get to Ra’s al Ghul. But before the can get Dimentieva to speak, she is executed by Kaliber, Karma, and Ishmael. Having trailed Black Lightning, the rest of the Outsiders (Katana, Orphan, and Signal) arrive to better the odds. After suffering defeat at the hands of the Outsiders (and Shiva), the villains detonate bombs in order to escape. Shiva, impressed by her new comrades, unofficially joins the Outsiders! Meanwhile, Batman begins training Sofia Ramos. Later, in the Batcave, Batman officially enters Shiva and Sofia into the Outsiders lineup. Batman and Black Lightning have a heart-to-heart alongside the graves of Thomas and Martha Wayne. Likewise, Shiva and Cassie have a mother-daughter heart-to-heart as well (while sparring, of course). Black Lightning then has another heart-to-heart with Katana. The next day, the Outsiders travel to Khadym and ride horseback to Ra’s al Ghul’s fortress, which a retro-fitted alien spaceship. Inside, they find the corpse of Kaliber, who has been executed by the League of Assassins. Ishmael, having also been fatally-wounded, delivers a holographic message from his former master. Ra’s al Ghul gloats, using his alien super-weapon to completely demolish Shiva’s hometown in China. The Outsiders have lost round one, but they vow to bring Ra’s al Ghul to justice.

–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1028. Batman begins keeping tabs on GCPD Officer Richard Gotis, a highly corrupt but untouchable cop. Batman also takes note of good cops too, specifically Officer Christopher Nakano. The Dark Knight will keep tabs on these policemen for months to come.

–Detective Comics #1017 Epilogue
Around two months have passed since the conclusion of the main action of Detective Comics #1017. Bruce, Damian, and Lucius Fox attend the grand opening of the new Miguel Flores Wing at the Martha Wayne Orphanage.

–Batman Giant Vol. 2 #2 (Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #3)
After twelve international industrialists are murdered by their own bodyguards, Batman is on the case. The clues point him in the direction of a logging camp in the rain forests of Brazil. Thinking the League of Assassins might be involved, Batman preps by creating some mini-surveillance drones and new prototype knockout pods. At the logging camp, Batman is surprised to find that Poison Ivy is responsible for the murders. These are Poison Ivy’s first murders in her entire career as a super-villain. It’s true, she’s never killed before. But now, sadly, she’s crossed that line, seemingly become more plant than human. (We’ll see Poison Ivy continue her murderous ways in the upcoming Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 4.) Batman brings down Poison Ivy, bringing her back to Gotham to be imprisoned. Later, Bruce purchases the logging camp with a directive to turn it into a nature preserve.

–REFERENCE: In Batman and The Outsiders Vol. 3 #15. An Illuminati-like secret cabal of international corporate leaders in tech, real estate, and media—known as The Master Group—put out feelers to Bruce and Lex Luthor, inviting them both to join their illustrious ranks. Bruce and Lex both reject them. The Master Group includes moguls Jennifer Cunningham and four unnamed others.


–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1027. Batman begins hounding suspected murderer Balsam, a master craftsman and electrical engineer.

–Batman/Superman Vol. 2 #7-8 (“THE KANDOR COMPROMISE”)
Batman and Superman capture a pair of King Kongs, delivering them to Monster Rock. They then fight a series of successive battles against Bizarro #1, Prankster and his giant robot, Magog, Clock King II (Temple Fugate) and his giant robot, and Dr. Destiny. Batman and Superman then use their new algorithm, which sends them to the cemetery at Stryker’s Island Prison. There, they examine the remains of Kryptonite Man only to be attacked by Ra’s al Ghul, who is on a hunt for Kryptonite. Ra’s al Ghul tells them that Zod has taken the shattered Bottle City of Kandor, complete with thousands of microscopic corpses, with plans to resurrect them all via Lazarus Pit. Batman, Superman, and Ra’s al Ghul travel to an ancient Aztec temple in Mexico, site of a Lazarus Pit. There, the trio finds Ra’s al Ghul’s elite League of Lazarus beaten to a pulp. Zod emerges and dumps Kandor into the Lazarus Pit. Thousands of tiny out-of-control Kandorians emerge and swarm like killer bees. Batman, Superman, Ra’s al Ghul, and Zod are forced to defend themselves against the swarm. Eventually, Ra’s al Ghul uses a red sun grenade to take out the entire swarm. Zod puts the Kandorians back into their bottle. They are fully resurrected (and de-powered), but no one knows when their aggressive Lazarus state will wear off. Angry at having been used by Zod, Ra’s al Ghul destroys the bottle. Zod flips out and begins fighting Ra’s al Ghul. Batman is able to talk Zod our of murdering Ra’s al Ghul. Batman then meets with Superman at the Fortress of Solitude where the Man of Steel has saved the Kandorians but putting them into coma-like stasis, in which they will remain until a safer form of resurrection is discovered. Superman tells Batman that Zod has taken half of the Kandorians. Zod, with his Kandorians also in a similar stasis, returns to his planet of Jekuul.

–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1021. Batman stops a crook from mugging the nephew of GCPD medical examiner Dr. Woodard. Batman meets Dr. Woodard and will visit her at the police morgue on several occasions in the next month (although we’ll have to imagine these visits on our timeline).

–Batman and The Outsiders Vol. 3 #13-16 (“THE DEMON’S FIRE”)
Batman and Black Lightning discuss how they have been in a nervous waiting game in regard to Ra’s al Ghul, who still has possession of an alien WMD. Batman introduces Black Lightning to Martian Manhunter, who has agreed to help them fight Ra’s al Ghul. (Hard to believe Black Lightning has never met Martian Manhunter before but okay, sure.) Meanwhile, the rest of the Outsiders train. Seemingly with Katana’s blessing, Shiva takes Cassie and Duke to her hotel, urging them to break ranks with the Outsiders and go after Ra’s al Ghul with her instead of Batman. Duke and Cassie, sick of sitting on the bench, agree with the idea. Batman, secretly in league with Shiva, allows Duke and Cassie to depart with her. In the Batcave, Batman plugs Black Lightning into his electromagnetic amplification chair. Batman, Black Lightning, Sofia Ramos, and Katana enter Khadym to wallop League of Assassins soldiers and level houses. Black Lightning uses his augmented power to begin searching for Ra’s al Ghul’s super-weapon. Meanwhile, in conjunction with Batman’s plan, Shiva, Signal, and Orphan rough-up Ra’s al Ghul’s banker, learning that the Demon’s Head has relocated to Tokyo, Japan. The fully-reassembled Outsiders beat up a cyberpunk arms dealer in Tokyo, learning that Ra’s al Ghul is targeting the Illuminati-like Master Group. Sure enough, Ra’s al Ghul takes control of the Master Group and announces—via live TV broadcast—that he is purging the world with his WMD. While Orphan bests the entire League of Assassins by herself, Black Lightning and Ra’s al Ghul face off against one another in Dragon Ball Super-esque showdown, pitting god power versus god power. Black Lightning easily destroys Ra’s al Ghul’s weapon and disposes of him. Batman honors his team, and tells them he has an important message for them when they return to Gotham.

–Batman and The Outsiders Vol. 3 #17
Bruce buys a horse ranch for Sofia Ramos. The Outsiders all meet at Sofia’s ranch. Bruce tells Sofia that he hopes she remains a crimefighting vigilante, but the choice is hers and hers alone. Tatsu and Jefferson chat, declaring that the Outsiders are now officially disbanded. At the ranch, a smiling Bruce hosts a lighthearted dinner for the Outsiders. Bruce then has a touching conversation with Cassie, telling her that he never invited her to be a Batgirl or a Robin because he wanted her to walk her own path in life. Bruce and Cassie have a lovely father-daughter moment and hug each other in a warm embrace. Over tea, Bruce chats with Shiva, but the latter drugs him, giving her ample opportunity to get one-on-one time with Sofia, who decides that she wants to distance herself from Bruce’s gifts and join up with Shiva. When Bruce awakes, everyone has left except Shiva. Shiva tells Bruce to butt out of Sofia’s life for good. Bruce sulks at his empty ranch house.

–Batman/Superman Vol. 2 #9-11 (“ATOMIC”)
In Gotham, Batman fights Atomic Skull. During their fight, Batman recaps Atomic Skull’s history, of which he is familiar from his detailed crime-files. Realizing that the SWAT team assisting him are a bunch of phonies, Batman helps Atomic Skull fend them off, after which the “cops” drop dead, revealing that they were re-animated remote-controlled corpses the entire time. Atomic Skull then tragically dies, exploding in a mini nuclear blast. Meanwhile, Lois and Clark try to go on a dinner date in Paris, but they are swarmed by paparazzi. Superman departs to clean-up the blast damage in Gotham and to rescue Batman. In a cave near Gotham Harbor, the culprit behind it all—the Ultra-Humanite—prepares for an onslaught. After an autopsy, Batman finds pilfered WayneTech, LexCorp, Kord Industries, and STAR Labs detonator tech inside Atomic Skull’s body. Batman and Superman visit Gotham Industrial Clean Waste where they are attacked by Ultra-Humanite-controlled zombies. Ultra-Humanite captures Batman and surgically implants a nuclear device inside the Dark Knight’s head. Controlled by a strange device strapped to his neck and arms, Batman is forced to fight against Superman. Superman destroys the controller device, allowing Batman to zap Ultra-Humanite out with a taser. Ultra-Humanite’s brain is then sent to STAR Labs. Superman attends Atomic Skull’s funeral before joining Lucius Fox in the Batcave. Superman and Lucius watch as Bruce performs robotic surgery on himself, fixing up the damage Ultra-Humanite did to him. Batman and Superman discuss the fact that someone had been holding Atomic Skull hostage prior to Ultra-Humanite taking control of him. (Unknown to Batman and Superman, Atomic Skull was being secretly held by Robin in the latter’s torture dungeon under Mercy Hall.) In Metropolis, Atomic Skull resurrects, emerging from his grave.

–Batman Secret Files #3 Part 3
Batman learns that a new assassin named Mr. Teeth plans on killing a woman in the suburbs outside of Gotham. The Dark Knight shows up just in time to save her and bust the villain.

–Justice League Vol. 4 #40-43 (“INVASION OF THE SUPERMEN”)
Scott Snyder tweeted that “Invasion of the Supermen” occurs prior to “Justice/Doom War.” I usually don’t arrange the chronology based upon what creators say outside of the comics themselves, especially when said creator isn’t even the writer of the title in question—but this one is actually fact, hence placement here. Former Green Lantern Sodam Yat violently crashes on Earth and is taken into the care of the Justice League at the Hall of Justice. Sodam Yat explains that the Eradicator has created a cloned army of Daxamite warriors that are coming to Earth. (Sodam Yat is a Daxamite, an alien species that descended from Kryptonians, so they are very similar.) Wonder Woman suggests that they consult Madame Xanadu for special magick to use against the hordes from Daxam. Justice League Vol. 4 #40 tells us outright that: the JL—sans John Stewart—hasn’t met Sodam Yat before; the JL—sans Wonder Woman—hasn’t met Madame Xanadu before; and Flash has never met nor even heard of the Eradicator before. As far-fetched as that all may seem (especially Flash’s ignorance), the combination of facts listed above are indeed possible, I guess. While Superman and John Stewart chat about the former’s recent decision to tell the world his secret ID, Batman—with sad thoughts of the dearly departed Alfred on his mind—visits London in search of Madame Xanadu. Madam Xanadu finds Batman first and she isn’t pleased that he’s come a-calling. Eventually, however, Batman is able to win her over. Sensing the danger involved with the current battle against the Eradicator, Batman orders the evacuation of the Hall of Justice. In Metropolis, Superman, Wonder Woman, John Stewart, and Flash face off against Eradicator and the “Advance Legion” of his Daxamite army. The heroes struggle mightily until Batman and Madame Xanadu come and bail them out by teleporting them to the safety of the Scottish Highlands. However, an unconscious Wonder Woman gets accidentally left behind. Eradicator kidnaps Wonder Woman, smashes his way into the Hall of Justice, and delivers a live global broadcast, declaring himself as the new ruler of Earth. Soon after, Sodom Yat and the heroes combat the Eradicator and his army yet again. The bad guys foolishly chase Flash, who lures them through a Madame Xanadu-created portal and onto a distant planetary system that doesn’t have a yellow sun. On this alien planet, with the playing field evened, the heroes kick the villains’ asses. Eradicator is so disappointed in his troops that he tries to kill them all. The JL stops him from doing so. While Superman distracts Eradicator, Wonder Woman chops his head clean off with her sword! The Green Lantern Corps then brings all the Daxamites into custody. Back on Earth, Batman invites Madame Xanadu to join the main JL roster, but she turns him down. She gives him a tarot reading, telling him that a great obstacle lies ahead for the JL. (A reference in Justice League Vol. 4 Annual #2 tells us that the JL puts the Eradicator’s severed robot head into one of the Hall of Justice’s laboratories.)

–Robin 80th Anniversary 100-Page Spectacular Part 5
February—Bruce’s birthday. Jason finds Thomas Wayne’s watch, which he promised to fix for Bruce over a decade ago. After fixing the watch, Red Hood leaves it for Batman as a birthday gift.

–Robin 80th Anniversary 100-Page Spectacular Part 10
Batman suspects that something is terribly wrong with Damian. As such, he meets with his son, hoping to speak to him. But when they chat, Batman is stifled and unable to properly communicate. Instead, father and son patrol together in silence. Unknown to Batman, Damian has been kidnapping, torturing, and mind-wiping super-villains in his secret Teen Titans dungeon. He’s been doing this for two years now, but things have gotten much darker and violent lately. (Don’t forget—as per reference in Flash #761—an unsuspecting Robin and Kid Flash have both been pushed toward using unsavory anti-crime methods by Reverse-Flash Eobard Thawne, who has used the Negative Speed Force to put dark subliminal messages into their subconsciouses.) Soon, they come across Quietus, who commands an entire army of robot doppelgängers of himself. Together, they defeat all the bad guys. Unable to have a father-son chat, father and son part ways.

–Teen Titans Vol. 6 #42-44[2]
The Teen Titans recently mind-wiped Brother Blood. When Brother Blood turns up dead in New York City, the team decides to investigate, searching the sewer where his corpse turned up. There, the teens fight some Church of Blood cultists and stop a plot to release deadly toxins into NYC. The mystery of who killed Brother Blood remains unsolved. Meanwhile, in Wayne Manor, a pensive Batman looks at a chessboard and a broken picture frame containing a photo of Alfred and Damian. The Dark Knight’s son is absent and his father-figure is gone. Thinking of their recent interaction in Robin 80th Anniversary 100-Page Spectacular Part 10, a disheartened Batman wonders what Damian could be up to. In Brooklyn, Superboy (Jonathan Kent) travels to the present from the 31st century to check up on Damian. Later, Robin’s Teen Titan teammates come to believe that he’s killed Brother Blood, so they confront him just as he’s about to ambush KGBeast. Robin admits to the murder, which leads to the Teen Titans fighting him. Robin fends-off his acquaintances, claiming that he plans on executing KGBeast as well. Robin charges at KGBeast and chops his robo-arm off. While KGBeast escapes from Kid Flash, the rest of the Teen Titans fight Robin, who escapes as well. Batman infiltrates Mercy Hall, learning that Robin had been kidnapping super-villains and holding them there. At a former Janus Cosmetics building, Black Mask gathers Gizmo, Mammoth, Onomatopoeia, Joystick, Swerve, and Deathstroke. The villains plot revenge against Robin. A day later, Robin and his fellow Teen Titans confront each other yet again, but this time Batman interrupts.

–Teen Titans Vol. 6 Annual #2
Picking up directly from Teen Titans Vol. 6 #44, Batman confronts Robin, accusing him of kidnapping, torture, and murder. Before things can heat up, Deathstroke nearly kills everyone with a rocket launcher. Batman tells the Teen Titans they are finished before departing. Soon afterward, despite their differences, the Teen Titans assist Robin in a fight against Deathstroke. Robin’s recklessness injures Red Arrow and allows Deathstroke to escape. Batman once again approaches Robin, telling him that he’s behaving out of character. Batman and Robin fight, with the former soon realizing that the latter hasn’t been able to properly deal with the tragic loss of Alfred. Batman tells Robin that he loves him and that he has failed him as a father, to which Robin tears off his chest emblem. Robin says he’s no longer the Boy Wonder and walks off in anger. (Don’t forget—as per reference in Flash #761—an unsuspecting Robin and Kid Flash have both been pushed toward using unsavory super-villain-ish methods by Reverse-Flash Eobard Thawne, who has used the Negative Speed Force to put dark subliminal messages into their subconsciouses.)

–DC’s Crimes of Passion #1 Part 7
Nightjar returns to Gotham, ripping off Penguin. Batman notifies Slam Bradley, who tells the Dark Knight he must handle the situation solo. Bradley meets with his old flame and helps her escape from Penguin’s henchmen.

–REFERENCE: In Superman Vol. 5 #23. John Constantine helps Batman on an unspecified case, after which Superman hears about it.

–REFERENCE: In Superman Vol. 5 #23. Lois Lane, Batman, and some of Superman’s other friends, looking out for his mental health, ask him to go through a mystical check-up and therapy session with the new Dr. Fate (Khalid Nassour).

–Strange Adventures Vol. 5 #1-3
Adam Strange and his wife Alanna have relocated to Earth from Rann, following the destruction of Ranagar during a war against the robotic alien race known as the Pykkts—a conflict that has supposedly left their daughter (Aleena Strange) dead. Having dealt with his grief by writing a memoir about his experience, Adam recently completed a book tour and was awarded a Congressional Medal of Honor (about a month ago). As such, things are going relatively okay for Adam—until he is publicly accused of interplanetary war crimes and his accuser subsequently is murdered by an Adam Strange-like ray gun. Adam immediately goes to Batman for help, asking the Dark Knight to vouch for him and assist in clearing his name. Batman says they have too close of a personal history together, so he cannot get involved. However, Batman sanctions a Justice League-sponsored investigation and sets Adam up with Mr. Terrific, who has instructions to solve the case and (hopefully) clear Adam’s name. Mr. Terrific says he will read Adam’s book and do some preliminary outreach before officially accepting the job. After reading the book a few times, Mr. Terrific checks-in with Batman via phone. Batman chats with him while busting an escaped Professor Pyg. Later, Mr. Terrific deduces that Aleena is secretly still alive. Curious, Mr. Terrific phones Batman to accept the case. The hero of Rann goes to Superman and Hawkman for advice, but they don’t put his mind at ease. (Don’t forget that, at this juncture, Hawkman is still an infected “Secret Six” member under the influence of Sky Tyrant, although he is clearly doing just fine here. Plus, Tom King wouldn’t touch that storyline with a hundred foot pole here anyway, and I don’t blame him.) Uncomfortable about being questioned about Aleena’s death, Adam and Alanna seek advice from a lawyer, but he says the JL isn’t to be messed with in the courts. Soon after, a news leak gives some case details to the press, notably highlighting the JL’s role in the investigation and spreading rumor that the Pykkts could threaten Earth as revenge against Adam Strange. When public opinion turns on the Stranges, they take to the daytime talk show circuit to defend their privacy (and to smear Mr. Terrific). At the Strange household, Batman pays a visit to Alanna, reminding her that Adam came to him for help. Batman questions why Alanna is pushing back so adamantly and publicly against the JL. As they argue, someone snaps a photo of them, which gets leaked to the press.

–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1024. Bruce hears a rumor that an inert Lincoln March has been disavowed by the Court of Owls and buried in their secret “Tomb of the Unworthy.”

–REFERENCE: In Strange Adventures Vol. 5 #5. Batman and Superman notify the superhero community not to speak with Adam Strange while the Pykkt investigation is still ongoing. Soon after, Batman takes down a robotic murder-drone (supposedly of Pykkt origin) in Gotham. This leads to a congressional hearing, which in turn leads to asshole President Trump creating an anti-Pykkt task force led by Adam Strange and Alanna Strange—much to the chagrin of the Justice League.

–REFERENCE: In Suicide Squad Vol. 6 #6. Batman hears about Arkham Asylum inmate Dr. Pacat, who escapes from the prison by stabbing three guards with a spoon.

–Batman Secret Files #3 Part 4
When a new assassin named Gunsmith (Douglas Worth) murders several folks and takes control of a Wayne Enterprises building that is running a weapons-return amnesty program, Batman is on the case. After researching his foe, Batman infiltrates the boobytrapped premises only to find that Gunsmith has taken a hostage. The hostage’s brother, manipulated by Gunsmith, shoots Batman at point blank range, winging him. Batman rescues the abductee, but Gunsmith escapes clean. Afterward, Batman takes the gun from the kidnap victim’s brother and calms him down.

–Batman Giant Vol. 2 #5 Part 1 Epilogue (Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #7 Epilogue)
The latest of Bruce’s donations to Arkham Asylum has purchased new higher-quality living spaces for the inmates. Bruce is given a tour of the new facilities, finding that the prisoners are in much better spirits as a result.



–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1024. Batman begins carrying Mr. Freeze’s ice weaponry and some sanitization pellets in his utility belt.

–Suicide Squad Vol. 6 #6
With their government handler dead, the Suicide Squad is free and hellbent on going after the money man behind the latest version of Task Force X—Ted Kord! (SPOILER: Ted is actually a disguised Black Mask.) The latest Suicide Squad lineup (Harley Quinn, Deadshot, Chaos Kitten, The Aerie, Deadly Six, Fin, Osita, Thylacine, Zebra-Man, Wink, and an unnamed pet dog) heads to Gotham to have their brain bombs removed by Dr. Pacat. After surgery, Harley Quinn and Deadshot learn that they’ve finally been fully pardoned for all their crimes thanks to having completed enough Suicide Squad missions. Amazing! When a big bounty goes out on the rogue Suicide Squad, Batman springs into action. After taking down Dr. Pacat and some would-be assassins, Batman confronts the Suicide Squad head-on. Despite ten-to-one odds, Batman holds his own. The entire Suicide Squad flees, leaving Deadshot and the puppy behind. Wink steals the Batmobile! Batman then fights Deadshot to a stalemate, after which Deadshot shows Batman his pardon.

–DC Cybernetic Summer #1 Part 10
Cyborg fights Cyborg Superman. Meanwhile, from the Synodic Transphase Zone (a realm outside of time and space), the Cyborg Superman of Earth-D/cosX19Y (Henry Victor Kentshaw ClarkStone) uses his vast cosmic power to influence Batman and Superman’s minds, causing them to intervene in Cyborg and Cyborg Superman’s fight via a preposterous ruse. Batman dons a bizarre robot disguise and calls himself “Super Cyborg Cyborg Superman” aka “SuCCS” (and even makes a fake Wikipedia page about this new persona). The appearance of Superman and SuCCS are enough to confuse Cyborg Superman, who is taken down by Cyborg. Confused yet? We learn that Earth-D/cosX19Y Cyborg Superman is only messing with Earth-0 affairs because he is in a Synodic Transphase Zone high-stakes poker game that involves betting actual Earths. Seated at the poker table are Harbinger, Kamandi, Reverse-Flash, and the Anti-Monitor! Harbinger is definitely an alternate universe version of the original. The others are very likely alternate universe versions as well.

–REFERENCE: In Justice League Vol. 4 #44. Aquaman secretly returned from his long absence (ever since “Drowned Earth,” where he had been mistakenly believed to be dead) about nine months ago. Cut to now. Aquaman and Mera have a baby (as seen in Aquaman Vol. 8 #57)! Mera gives birth to their daughter Andy. Aquaman not only surprises the the Justice League with his presence, but also notifies them of Andy’s arrival into the world. Note that Aquaman’s re-appearance here directly contradicts his dramatic re-appearance in the upcoming “Justice/Doom War” (Justice League Vol. 4 #30-39). This error exists because a bunch of Justice League issues were released out of order. Because “Justice/Doom War” leads directly into Dark Nights: Death Metal, Justice League Vol. 4 #30-39 (October 2019 to March 2020) occurs AFTER Justice League Vol. 4 #40-52 (April to December 2020). You can see how continuity got screwed up as a result.

–REFERENCE: In Justice League Vol. 4 Annual #2. Batman begins working on a top secret microbot/nanobot defense system inside the Hall of Justice.

–FLASHBACK: From Detective Comics #1027 Part 3. Early May. An escaped Joker celebrates Batman’s “birthday” by kidnapping him, unmasking him, and strapping him to a chair for electro shock therapy. Note that while Joker obviously knows Batman’s secret ID, the bluntness of removing his mask feels a bit more post-“Joker War” than pre-“Joker War.” However, we can assume that Joker doesn’t care about Batman’s alter ego in this moment, so it’s not too big of a deal. In the flashback image, Joker isn’t even looking at Batman anyway. Batman escapes his electrified predicament.

–Justice League Vol. 4 #44-47 (“COLD WAR”)
Aquaman calls in the Justice League for help in the Southern (Antarctic) Ocean to deal with the spirits of Scylla, the Hydra, the Drakon, the Nemean lion, Cetus the serpent, a manticore, a griffin, a hippogriff, some rocs, and other creatures of myth that have escaped from Tartarus. Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and John Stewart join with Aquaman and Atlantean troops to combat the creatures, during which the Javelin is totaled. Unknown to all, the creatures have been set free and prodded into combat by the Spectre. The heroes send the creatures back into he depths of Greco-Roman Hell, but the Spectre then causes the Justice League to succumb to their deepest jealousies, which leads to them battling each other. The heroes cool off and then confront the Spectre. Wonder Woman lassos him to learn the truth at the heart of the matter at hand. Jim Corrigan, sick of being bonded with the Spectre, traveled to a place outside of God’s jurisdiction: Tartarus. This has caused a fog of vengeance to permeate the entire planet. Unless our heroes can re-bond Corrigan with the Spectre, the planet is doomed. Hoping to access Tartarus, the JL travels to Themyscira. Upon arrival, the JL is greeted with Amazonian spears, arrows, and swords. Hippolyta calms her warriors and is about to let her daughter and company pass, but the Spectre causes the Amazons to attack. While John Stewart stays behind to fend off the Amazons, the rest of the JL ventures down into Tartarus. In the abyss, they find Corrigan and the great god Tartarus (for whom the Hellish realm is named). The evil god restrains the heroes and causes anger and hatred to spread across the globe. Seeing no other option, Corrigan re-bonds with the Spectre. The combined might of the heroes (along the the Amazons) is enough to defeat Tartarus.

–Justice League Vol. 4 #48-50 (“THE RULE”)
The Justice League fixes and upgrades the Javelin, using it to rescue a drifting spacecraft filled with alien children of the species known as The Trotha. The kids have been orphaned as a result of a brutal civil war between the Spark-worshippers and the Cell-worshippers of their society. Just as the JL arrives on the rogue comet home world of the Trotha, they find that a revolt by enslaved aliens has deposed the tyrant Empress Siddinix. (Writer Si Spurrier refers to revolting enslaved aliens as a “lynch mob,” which is not only bizarre, but also fairly offensive.) Superman prevents the formerly enslaved aliens from executing the queen, taking her into custody instead. The JL then chats with the leaders of the the Spark-worshippers and Cell-worshippers, who beg the JL to become the new rulers of the planet. All of a sudden, a weird brain-like alien slug in an even more bizarre looking mech appears, citing that the warmongering Vermidiim race is coming to colonize the Trotha. He detonates himself in a suicide attack, but the heroes save everyone present. All JLers but Wonder Woman agree to assume temporary leadership of the Trotha to help them repel the impending invasion. For four days, Batman, Flash, Superman, and John Stewart try to prep the Trotha for war, but they fail to understand their culture, causing even more problems. Wonder Woman, who has taken the time to actually talk to people and learn about the Trotha, chastises her teammates for their screw-ups. Eventually, Wonder Woman joins Superman, Flash, and John Stewart to repel the Vermidiim invasion in space. Meanwhile, Batman audio-records his friends in battle, but they say some upsetting pro-war things that get leaked to the Trotha populace. This causes the Spark-worshippers and Cell-worshippers to unite and attack Batman while attempting to put Siddinix back on the throne. Siddinix mind-controls Batman, sending him to regroup with the rest of the returning JL. However, Wonder Woman realizes something is off and lassos Batman, returning him to his senses. Batman pretends that he’s still under Siddinix’s control and the JL begins a massive ruse to stop her chicanery and end the war. The JL tries to broker a peace treaty between the Vermidiim and united Trotha, but they seemingly fail yet again. (It’s all part of the sting operation.) Soon after, the Trotha factions restart their civil war, but Batman (still pretending to be under Siddinix’s thumb) tricks the Cell-worshippers and Spark-Worshippers into joining together to combat the lingering Vermidiim. Just as all hope seems lost and Siddinix regains her throne, the JL turns the tables on the despot, exposing her evil to the Trotha. An angry citizenry apprehends Siddinix and turns her over to the Vermidiim, ending the conflict. The Trotha also end their pointless civil war at home as well.

–Justice League Vol. 4 #51-52 (“THE GARDEN OF MERCY”)
Picking up directly from Justice League Vol. 4 #50, the Justice League flies back home from the Trotha planet. A mysterious force summons them to a distant seemingly dead planet. Upon investigating the surface, our heroes find humanoid beings attached to towering Black Mercy trees. The forest quickly ensnares the heroes, putting them each into hallucinatory states. The heroes are able to fight their way out and destroy the Black Mercy. Back home on Earth, Superman debriefs with Batman.

–Justice League Vol. 4 Annual #2
When a fresh corpse turns up inside the Hall of Justice, the Justice League is on the case. Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Flash, and John Stewart are soon attacked by all the technology inside the Hall of Justice, forcing them to fight against their own HQ. Eventually, the heroes discover that the Eradicator’s severed robot head has taken control of the entire complex. The JL regains control and locks Eradicator’s head away into a safer place.

–Shazam! Vol. 3 #14
In the alternate dimension known as the Magiclands, which connects to a mashed-up Oz and Wonderland (aka the Wozenderlands) and other fantastical places, the Shazam Family, including new member CC Batson (Billy Batson’s dad), battles against the Monster Society of Evil (Mr. Mind, Dr. Thaddeus Sivana, Black Adam, Evil Eye, Jeepers, King Kull, Mr. Atom, Mr. Merry-Go-Round, the Red Queen, Scapegoat, the Crocodile-Men, the Wicked Witch of the West, some flying monkeys, and some evil clowns). With his adoptive parents (Rosa Vasquez and Victor Vasquez), Tawky Tawny, the White Rabbit (from Alice in Wonderland), and the Scarecrow (from The Wizard of Oz) watching, Shazam defeats the Monster Society. (Don’t forget, Shazam is still technically suffering from his Dark Joker infection, but that doesn’t come into play in this story. He’s totally fine.) However, Superboy-Prime, having been released from a dungeon in the Monsterlands, attacks! Sensing the greater threat, Black Adam turns face and helps Shazam defeat Superboy-Prime. Shazam then does a spell that prevents the Magiclands from merging with Philadelphia. As the Magiclands fade into the ether, Shazam hears cries for help from Dorothy Gale and the Cowardly Lion (from The Wizard of Oz) and Humpty Dumpty (from the Mother Goose nursery rhyme). He vows to return to help them one day. CC Batson loses his powers along with any memories about what has occurred. With no desire to reconnect with his son, CC departs, leaving Shazam heartbroken. Black Adam officially takes CC’s place in the Shazam Family. The Monster Society members get locked up in Rock Falls Penitentiary while Superboy-Prime gets locked up at the Hall of Justice. The Shazam Family (sans Black Adam) then hangs out with the Justice League. (Note that Aquaman is drawn very generically, with short hair and no beard, which is a continuity error.)

–Detective Comics #1027 Part 1
Batman gets kayoed and winds up restrained in a high-tech underwater death trap. The Dark Knight escapes and busts the man responsible, Balsam.

–Detective Comics #1027 Part 7
Bruce is notified that, thanks to new WayneTech “wavefinder” scanning devices, the annual SS Odyssey salvage team believes it has found the long hidden location of Patrick Wayne’s ill-fated floating art museum, which sunk in 1937. Live from Wayne Manor, Bruce speaks about the impending salvage dive as part of an interview for the podcast Impossible But True, hosted by Roy Raymond Jr (former Owlman and grandson of the original TV show host). A day later in the Atlantic, Bruce joins Raymond and his crew—Martin Compass (grandson of Captain Mark Compass), Sandra Bradley (granddaughter of Slam Bradley and daughter of Sam Bradley), and Cathy Saunders (granddaughter of Cyril “Speed” Saunders) for the dive. Bruce, having been tipped off by international law enforcement that there could be a mole aboard the boat, feigns illness to stay behind on the yacht above. He finds Compass gagged-and-bound in a back room. The mole, having swapped places with Compass, joins the others to locate the long lost Odyssey shipwreck. They find that all the art has already been removed. The mole finds a map leading to the lost treasures, takes it, and returns to the surface with plans to eliminate the seasick Bruce. Of course, Batman is waiting for the guy. With a little help from Raymond, Batman takes him down. Later, Bruce and the Impossible But True crew follow the map to recover the art.


–Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #17 Part 1
Batman chases an escaped Scarecrow and his minions to the alligator-filled Slaughter Swamp outside of Gotham City. After getting dosed with a new strain of Fear Gas, Batman is saved by Swamp Thing. Wearing Swamp Thing akin to a 616-Venom-like symbiote suit, a jacked-up Batman busts Scarecrow and his henchmen.

–Detective Comics #1020-1022 (“UGLY HEART”)
Two-Face has gotten even more unhinged since we last saw him in “City of Bane.” Having blackouts and switching randomly switching back-and-forth between his good side and his evil side, Two-Face has started a new cult called The Church of the Two and permanently acid-scarred the entire left side of his body to match his face. After Two-Face brutally murders the notorious DeMarco Brothers, Batman visits the scene of the homicide to gather evidence, instantly recognizing the famous gangsters from his vast criminal databases. An injured Two-Face gets fixed up at an urgent care center, but then kills his doctor. This prompts his cult followers to torch the place. Batman shows up mid-arson and kicks their asses, but they all commit suicide rather than tell the Dark Knight what Two-Face is up to. After examining the corpses, Batman discovers they all had terminal illnesses. The clues lead Batman to the courthouse, but while en-route he runs into a panicked Two-Face. Two-Face appears in his Harvey Dent persona, importuning Batman for help, citing that he’s not in control of his other half at all anymore. Batman cuffs Two-Face in the Batmobile and heads into the basement of the courthouse. There, he finds Two-Face’s cult. Meanwhile, Two-Face reverts back to his evil persona, breaks free of his cuffs, and descends into the basement with guns a-blazing. Two-Face captures Batman and dumps him into a vat of acid, but Batman escapes unscathed and even saves the lives of every single cult member when the acid bath floods the room. Batman then prevents two cultists from blowing up a children’s hospital, discovering that all Church members have terminal illnesses and their families were paid large sums of cash in exchange for their loyalty to Two-Face. Batman also learns that a faceless Joker, Hugo Strange, and Mad Hatter saved Two-Face’s life after he attempted suicide (by shooting himself in the head) four years ago. (Joker implanted a mind-control microchip alongside the bullet, which remains lodged in Two-Face’s brain to this day.) The cultist under Batman’s interrogation reveals that he—along with another cultist named Versa—is secretly working for Joker as a mole within the Church. He says Joker has told them to follow all of Two-Face’s order to a tee. Meanwhile, across town, Joker blows open the Court of Owls’ Tomb of the Unworthy.

–Detective Comics #1023-1024
Picking up directly from Detective Comics #1022, Joker resurrects Lincoln March. Meanwhile, Batman shakes-down the usual suspects in search of Two-Face, instead finding his way to Hugo Strange and Mad Hatter. Batman beats them both up, learning that Joker is trying to control Two-Face via the microchip implanted in the bullet in his head. At the GCPD armory, Batman fights Two-Face, who dons one of Geri Powers’ old Bat-mech-suits. Batman fights Two-Face and destroys the chip in his head using some magnetized tech. On Joker’s behalf, Lincoln March leads an army of Talons against the Caped Crusader. Batman and Two-Face team-up to fight the Talons, defeating them. Batman then restrains Two-Face and performs brain surgery on him, removing the bullet from his head! Later, as Matches Malone, Batman visits Two-Face in prison to give him the bullet.

–REFERENCE: In Batgirl Vol. 5 #48. Jim Gordon is released from prison with court dates set in his future.

–REFERENCE: In Batman/Superman Vol. 2 #12. Batman hears all about the Metal Men fighting a Chemo in New York (as seen in Metal Men Vol. 4 #6-9). A device known as a Chemo Responsometer, created by Dr. Will Magnus, was responsible for conjuring up the monster. Batman studies up on the device.

–Batman/Superman Vol. 2 Annual #1
Bat-Mite and Mxyzptlk are up to their old tricks again. Arguing over who would win in a fight between Batman and Superman, the 5th Dimensional gods temporarily re-write reality in order to tell their epic stories of “Batman vs Superman.” Eventually, Batman and Superman, transformed into plastic action figures and brought to the 5th Dimension, realize their predicament. The heroes are able to trick Bat-Mite and Mxyzptlk into fighting each other, thus allowing for a return home and return to continuity normalcy. Bat-Mite and Mxyzptlk wind up as plastic action figures inside the Batcave, playthings for Ace the Bathound and Krypto.

–DC: The Doomed and The Damned #1 Part 2
Batman hears about multiple boys falling mysteriously ill and dying at an orphanage, supposedly due to supernatural causes. Taking the case, Batman preps some interdimensional detection equipment and obtains some Nth Metal weaponry from Dr. Fate. Soon afterward, Batman and the sibling of an afflicted child confront the grotesque monster known as Mr. Slowdeath, a Cthulhu-like creature that emerges from a mirror. Using his weapons, Batman exorcises the demon, thus saving the sick kid.

–Batman/Superman Vol. 2 #12 (“PLANET BRAINIAC”)
Guided by their special crime prediction algorithm, Batman and Superman travel to Hawaii to take on the Brimstone Brotherhood, a cult obsessed with resurrecting the original Apokoliptian Brimstone. Instead, the cult raises up a lava-fueled Chemo, which Batman and Superman are able to defeat. The heroes jail the villains and confiscate a stolen Chemo Responsometer. Later, while Batman and Superman debrief in the Batcave, the Bat-computer gets hacked. Bat-mechs, Batmobiles, Batplanes, Bat-drones, the T rex, and other networked Bat-stuff goes haywire and begins attacking the heroes. The Chemo Responsometer creates a new Chemo as well. This forces Batman to do a manual override of the entire Batcave, which shuts down the Batcave and everything inside of it. Amid a trashed Batcave, Batman finds a Kryptonian virus within his Bat-computer network. The restored Kandor has corrupted their algorithm with an ancient Brainiac signal. Superman and an injured Batman—who both don extra armor—send out a JL alert and record a video of explanation before following the path of the signal to its source on the dark side of the Moon. After they depart, Batwoman and Steel (John Henry Irons) respond to the alert and get filled-in by Batman’s video. (Steel mentions that Brainiac is currently partnered with Lex Luthor, and we get an editorial asterisk that says “See ‘Justice/Doom War’ .” Brainiac is absolutely partnered with Luthor at the moment, but this editorial notation should read “See ‘Metropolis Doom’ ” or “See Justice League Vol. 4” instead. “Justice/Doom War” has yet to occur.) On the Moon, Batman and Superman are captured by a bunch of Brainiac robots.

–REFERENCE: In Young Justice Vol. 3 #18. With the Robin moniker vacant, Batman and Conner Kent convince Tim to begin using it again. He ditches his Drake costume and becomes Robin once again. (Note that, as before, he will also be called “Red Robin” sometimes. Tim loves the name “Red Robin.”)

–REFERENCE: In Detective Comics #1028. With Mr. Terrific’s help, Batman creates a high-tech portable x-ray device.

–Batman Vol. 3 #86-88 (“THEIR DARK DESIGNS”)
Early summer—Penguin hints at the season in Batman Vol. 3 #94. The Bat-computer flags an alert on the deep web about a big assassin hit happening in Gotham in five days’ time. Batman soon discovers that Deathstroke, Cheshire, Merlyn, Gunsmith, and Mr. Teeth are the assassins that have been hired for the score. As Batman preps to fight them, he makes several visits to a Wayne Enterprises hospital construction site. On the night of the big hit, the new Wayne Enterprises Tricorner Yards Campus opens for business. As does the secret Hibernaculum bunker deep beneath it (and the five Micro-Batcaves hidden in the main building above). Batman gives Lucius Fox designs for a new hybrid super-vehicle called the Nightclimber, which Lucius immediately begins running through their autonomous tech-building factory. Later that night, Bruce and Selina attend the grand opening of the new campus, which also functions as an investment fundraiser gala. In attendance are Mayor Dunch and his wife Deborah Dunch. Bruce ditches in order to patrol and re-visit the hospital site. Meanwhile, the assassins enter Gotham, but Batman gets the jump on them, busting all five, starting with Deathstroke. (The bloody fight against Deathstroke is shown in Batman Secret Files #3 Part 5, which overlaps with Batman Vol. 3 #86.) In the Tricorner Yards Campus vault, Catwoman prevents a man from swapping out new blueprints with the current Tricorner Yards blueprints. The man then succumbs to a violent and poisonous death before the super-villain who hired the five assassins, known as the Designer, speaks through him, telling Catwoman he and his pals have big plans for the city. Meanwhile, Joker continues top secret plans of his own, ordering the execution of henchmen that know about his scheme. Upon hearing about the arrest of the five assassins, Riddler and Penguin both worry, knowing the Designer is in town. An unhinged Riddler, who has been tweaking on meth for six-and-a-half months (ever since Luthor visited him in Year of the Villain: The Riddler #1), panics while Penguin violently stabs his entire inner circle to death before gearing up for war. (Note that we are told that “City of Bane” and Year of the Villain: The Riddler #1 took place around three months ago, but in order to jibe with our specific early summer setting, it has to have been been six-and-a-half months ago.) Batman briefs with Catwoman before heading to the Black Block. There, he discovers that Cheshire is still on the loose, having been swapped out with a clay body double. Batman puts a poison-proof protective coating on his costume and then rockets himself out of the Nightclimber in the Bat-Shot, testing the dangerous vehicle on the fly. While the Dark Knight takes down Cheshire, Penguin infiltrates police HQ and opens the cell doors in the Black Block. So much for state-of-the-art security. Sheesh. Penguin kidnaps the prisoners. Meanwhile, Catwoman radios Riddler, reminding him that he, she, Penguin, and Joker made a deal with the mysterious Designer years ago, and now the latter has come to collect. In Gotham’s Potter’s Field, Catwoman digs up a grave and opens a casket revealing a corpse dressed up to look like Joker. Across town, Batman uses a brand new Lucius Fox-designed tech called The Echo, which can turn any car with a Wayne Enterprises engine into a temporary Batmobile. Guided by Lucius, Batman finds Penguin and the captive assassins. Freed, the assassins attack Batman and make their escape by slitting Penguin’s throat. Batman is able to stabilize Penguin, who tells him that the Designer is going after Bruce Wayne, putting into motion a plan that he, Riddler, Joker, and Catwoman initiated years ago. In the graveyard, Catwoman is attacked by several undertakers that are mind-controlled by the Designer. Harley Quinn shows up and rescues Catwoman.

–Batman Vol. 3 #89-91 (“THEIR DARK DESIGNS” Continued…)
Early summer. At Gotham’s Potter’s Field, Catwoman and Harley Quinn rough up the Designer’s undertaker henchmen. Harley tells Catwoman that the dead Joker corpse is an old Joker henchman, and Joker had left him there as part a lead-in for a big scheme he’s been planning against Batman. Merlyn and Cheshire attack next, keeping Harley and Catwoman on their toes. From a distance, Joker’s new girlfriend Punchline watches with keen interest. After busting Gunsmith and Mr. Teeth, Batman infiltrates Riddler’s not-so-secret lair and finds security footage of the Big Bad—the Designer. Batman tells Lucius to activate the BatSpawn drones. Lucius does so, sending them after Deathstroke (with Harley Quinn at the controls). Catwoman and Harley then show up at Riddler’s lair, meeting up with Batman. Meanwhile, Joker and Punchline forge ahead with their own scheme, prepping for engagements with the civilian alter-egos of each primary Bat-Family member. Atop the skyscrapers of Gotham, Catwoman tells Batman about the deal she and the other Bat-rogues made with the Designer years ago. The Designer offered to design the ultimate villainous plan for each of them in exchange for half the loot gained afterward. After approving Riddler, Penguin, and Catwoman’s plans, the Designer met with Joker, learning how sick and twisted the Clown Prince of Crime really was. (Joker’s wish was simply to take the Designer’s place.) This caused the Designer to renege, leading to Joker shooting him dead. But now, the Designer has seemingly returned and is out for revenge. Catwoman tells Batman the ultimate heist that she and the Designer came up with all those years ago involved robbing Wayne Enterprises of its entire fortune. While Batman fights Deathstroke, the Designer abducts all the other villains and sends mind-controlled cops after Catwoman and Harley Quinn. When the Designer cancels his contract with Deathstroke, Deathstroke decides to team-up with Batman. The unlikely duo fights against more mind-controlled cops. Riddler announces he is partnered with the Designer.

–Batman Vol. 3 #92-94 (“THEIR DARK DESIGNS” Conclusion)[6]
Early summer. Picking up directly from Batman Vol. 3 #91, a hospitalized Penguin, as usual, dodges any culpability in wrongdoing, much to the chagrin of Commissioner Bullock. Meanwhile, Riddler turns the entire city into a giant crossword puzzle using hard-light holographic walls that are rigged with explosives. Riddler challenges Batman on a live pirated TV broadcast to complete the puzzle, which Batman does while riding the Bat-Train (with Deathstroke) toward Riddler’s location inside Bruce Wayne’s office at Tricorner Yards. Once there, Batman kicks Riddler’s ass and tranquilizes Deathstroke. The Designer confronts Batman, revealing that he knows his secret ID. Across town, Catwoman and Harley Quinn dispatch with more zombie cops and then attempt to rob an underground hedge fund for super-villains (The Underbrokerage) run by the aptly named Underbroker (Harlan Graves) and his assistant known as Doorman. Punchline shows up to fight Harley Quinn while Catwoman makes a transfer of funds. Fearing exposure of Bruce’s secret life and theft of his assets, Catwoman orders the Underbroker to transfer Bruce’s entire portfolio into her super-villain account. In Bruce’ office, Batman sword-duels the Designer and unmasks him to reveal that he is still just a corpse—albeit a remote-controlled corpse like all the others. The Designer is still dead, killed by the hand of the Joker all those years ago. Who’s been pulling all the strings? Joker, of course. Deathstroke, having been working for Joker the entire time, shows up and stabs Batman in the leg. At the Underbrokerage, Punchline slits Harley’s throat and shoots Catwoman. On Punchline’s command, the Underbroker transfers all of Bruce’s assets—his personal fortune and Wayne Enterprises—into Joker’s account. Bruce is also publicly exposed as having embezzled millions and warrant is issued for his arrest. A bloody and battered Batman is nursed back to health by Lucius Fox, who tells him that he can’t play Alfred anymore and must instead focus his efforts on trying how to figure out how to save the company. Lucius tells Batman that his daughter, Dr. Tam Fox, is caring for an equally-injured Catwoman at Mercy Hospital. Batman has a quick phone chat with Catwoman before rushing over to the hospital only to find that she’s already gone—having been rescued by Penguin. Batman is then approached by Joker’s henchmen, who show him a cellphone video link upon which Joker taunts the Dark Knight and reveals that he’s already kidnapped Lucius. In a secret bunker beneath the Iceberg Lounge (i.e. the Cool Room), Penguin’s doctors tend to Catwoman, who wakes up to find herself hiding among a handful of other super-villains, who are all worried at the scope of Joker’s latest scheme. The New-52-styled Killer Moth is shown, but he’s decidedly different from the Rebirth version, so we must assume this is a different guy than the original. Utterly defeated and having lost everything, the bloody Batman ascends to the top of a skyscraper and beckons the heavens for sign, much like how he did on the night the bat crashed through his study window all those years ago. Thunder rumbles and lightning flashes across the sky, painting the image of a Bat-symbol briefly across the clouds. In the deceased Alfred’s name, Batman vows that he will “become a better bat.” The so-called Joker War has officially begin.

–Nightwing Vol. 4 #74
With the Joker War having just begun, Batman departs a chaotic Gotham en route toward Blüdhaven where a brainwashed Ric Gryason (controlled by Joker via a magick Court of Owls crystal) fights Batgirl, Red Hood, and Robin (Tim Drake). Joker and Punchline cheer from the sidelines. Bea Bennett wields the magick crystal, which restores all of Ric’s old memories. Finally, Dick is back! Joker and Punchline quickly flee the scene. Batman arrives just in time to greet Dick and celebrate the return of Nightwing. Bea runs away in tears, miserable about losing her boyfriend Ric.

–Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 Part 1
Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 Part 1 picks up directly from Nightwing Vol. 4 #74. Writer Dan Jurgens clearly had zero communication with “Joker War” scribe James Tynion IV because little to nothing of Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 meshes with Tynion’s main narrative at all. Jurgens also starts with the terrible continuity mistake of Dick exclaiming that he was shot in the head “months ago” when he was actually shot in the head nearly two years ago! I guess Dick has lost track of time during his “Ric” phase. Since Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 spans a full week but supposedly occurs prior to Batman Vol. 3 #100 (a nearly nonsensical editorial note ham-fisted onto page one), it must occur right here and now. There are bad contradictions and barely-fanwank-able errors too, which I will address as we come to them. Onto a synopsis. On Monday, Dick visits Alfred’s grave (as seen via flashback from Nightwing Vol. 3 #75 Part 2). Bruce asks Dick to move back into Wayne Manor, but Dick turns down the offer, so Bruce puts him up in a hotel instead. At the hotel, Dick reunites with Donna Troy and Garth. (Don’t forget Donna is still infected with Dark Joker Venom at this juncture, although the evil reaction only occurs sporadically i.e. pretty much everyone forgot about “The Infected” storyline as soon as it happened.) A day later, in Russia, KGBeast learns of Nightwing’s return, immediately heading to Gotham with plans to finish the job he started. A day after that, as the third day of the Joker War begins, Nightwing—still in his alternate costume—teams-up with Batgirl to clean clown gang members out of multiple Gotham neighborhoods. This scene reads like Joker has been beaten already, with Batgirl referring to the clowns as “remnants,” although it is misspelled “remnats.” Yes, this fucking miserable comic even has spelling errors. Great job!

–Detective Comics #1027 Part 12
Note that this item supposedly occurs on Bruce’s birthday, but we are not anywhere near February, so that must be ignored. The third day of the Joker War continues. Batman breaks into the Batcave and grabs as much gear as he can. He also takes a copy of the Black Casebook. After checking into a dingy hotel under a false name, Bruce phones Lucius Fox, who keeps him abreast of what is happening, informing him that the last secure Wayne Enterprises buildings have been broken into by Joker and his hooligans. The takeover is not only legally official, but now nearly physically complete as well. This prompts Batman to enter a records storage facility that has been heavily booby-trapped. GCPD Officers Bart and Christopher Nakano enter the facility as well. A bomb explodes, killing Officer Bart. Officer Nakano angrily blames Batman for his partner’s death.

–Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 Part 2
The Joker War enters its fourth day. Nightwing—still in his alternate costume—teams-up with Batman to take on more of Joker’s clowns. Batman, having gotten one of Nightwing’s proper costumes, leads him to a location where it has been put on display. They talk about his time as “Ric” in great detail. Nightwing isn’t sure if he’s ready to don his old togs, but he does take his costume. Overlapping with the fifth day of the Joker War below, Nightwing will wear his blue-and-black costume to visit Blüdhaven, where he will retire the substitute Team Nightwing (Malcolm Hutch, Colleen Edwards, Zak Edwards, and Alphonze Sapienza), meeting with Bea Bennett, and fighting KGBeast. Note that Nightwing, even though he’s now literally wearing his old costume, won’t really accept it until Batman Vol. 3 #99, in which Batman will re-give it to him again. The screwy continuity on this title—jeez, it’s bad. I’m doing the best I can, folks.

–Batman Vol. 3 #95-98 (“THE JOKER WAR”)
The Joker War begins its fifth day. Batman sends multiple remote-controlled Batmobiles to occupy Joker’s henchmen at the Gotham Reservoir. Meanwhile, Punchline drugs Lucius Fox with Joker Venom, forcing him to give her access to all of Batman’s weaponry and tech. Across town, Joker purchases the Monarch Theater and screen the Mark of Zorro before a packed house of laughing Joker Venom victims. Outside of Tricorner Yards, Harlan Graves—now representing all of Wayne Enterprises (i.e. Joker’s) legal affairs—tells Commissioner Bullock to clear his troops off Wayne Enterprises properties. Bullock tells Graves to get bent, citing that he won’t kowtow to Joker or recognize his fraudulent takeover. But the law is on Joker’s side and the GCPD backs down. Batman sneaks into one of his Micro-Batcaves located at Tricorner Yards, specifically the fifth Micro-Batcave, which was being reserved for special use after the Wayne Rebuild Project’s final completion. Inside, Batman fights Punchline and sees a shiny blue Bat-costume on display. Interestingly, Lucius designed the turquoise suit based upon blueprints he found in the Bat-computer, but neither Bruce nor Lucius have any idea where the design came from. (They clearly came from Alfred.) Batman succumbs to Punchline Venom and begins hallucinating, hearing Alfred’s voice. He tries to flee the building only to run into a Joker-controlled Batplane. An injured Harley Quinn rescues Batman, who slips into a coma for three days. Batman awakens to find that Gotham has spiraled into Joker-orchestrated chaos. A murderous anti-Joker vigilante known as Clownhunter has begun stalking Joker’s henchmen as well. Still having hallucinations and hearing Alfred’s voice, Batman enters the Monarch Theater where he is attacked by dozens of Jokerized zombies. Harley Quinn rescues Batman, bringing him to an underground lair built by Poison Ivy. Harley gives Batman an anti-toxin, but it makes Batman hallucinate even harder. Punchline invades Poison Ivy’s lair, fighting Harley Quinn again. Batman comes-to and kayos Punchline. Using the Bat-tery, Batman finds the GPS location of each remaining Bat-Family member, recruiting them for battle. As referenced in Batman Vol. 3 #99 and Catwoman Vol. 5 #25, Batman secretly communicates with Catwoman, coming up with a plan of action to solve his money problems. In Penguin’s villain lair, Catwoman recruits Riddler and Penguin onto her cause by lying and saying she wants to rob Joker and split the funds three ways.

–Detective Comics #1025-1026 (“THE JOKER WAR: COLLATERAL DAMAGE”)
This item spans only a few hours, occurring between Batman Vol. 3 #98 and Batman Vol. 3 #99. Batman monitors Batwoman fighting Joker’s henchmen in Aparo Park, but the Dark Knight eventually joins Batwoman and Harvey Bullock in a cemetery to help battle more henchmen and shoot down remote-controlled Bat-drones (now Joker-drones). Batman and Batwoman then team-up inside the Bat-Tank, smashing into the Wayne Enterprises Tricorner Campus. They destroy the weapons factory and rescue Lucius Fox, administering an antitoxin to help dilute the Joker Venom in his bloodstream. Batman then hears through the grapevine that Killer Croc has turned over a new leaf and is avoiding Joker’s war at all costs. Thus, Batman is surprised when he learns Croc is kidnapping people. Batman chases Croc into the sewers, finding that he’s turned his victims into his half human-half animal henchmen (via toxic sludge). Croc tells Batman he plans on creating an army of similar henchmen. Batman defeats Croc in combat, after which the villain surrenders, allowing the Dark Knight to take him and his new buddies into Arkham Asylum. While Batman provides treatment to the mutated folks, Croc chats with Batman, apologizing for his actions. They have a touching heart-to-heart and shake hands.

–Batman Vol. 3 #99-100 (“THE JOKER WAR” Conclusion)
Picking up directly from Detective Comics #1025-1026, Joker travels to Ace Chemicals and touches base with Punchline via phone. His clown henchmen have begun herding the populace of Gotham into theaters with plans of mass murder in mind. (She escaped scot-free after being defeated by Batman earlier in the day.) Batman, despite having given Dick his old Nightwing costume, still doesn’t know if he’s truly accepted it. As such, Batman breaks into a Wayne Enterprises micro-cave and gets another Nightwing costume for Dick. The Dark Knight then assembles the Bat-Family (Nightwing, Red Hood, Red Robin, Spoiler, Signal, Orphan, Batgirl, and Harley Quinn) atop a Gotham roof. He tasks them with saving Gotham, delivering Dick his old costume as well. Dick officially (for the second time, thanks continuity masters) accepts his true Nightwing costume. Meanwhile, as seen in Catwoman Vol. 5 #25, Catwoman is able to steal back all of Bruce’s money and property, which legally transfers to a bunch of charities and to Lucius Fox. Lucius becomes the new multi-billion dollar CEO of Wayne Enterprises. While the Bat-Family spreads out across Gotham, Batman makes his way to Ace Chemicals. Harley Quinn says that it’s time to kill Joker and end the cycle of senseless murder and mayhem. Batman tells her he will never take a life, not even Joker’s. Batman then enters Ace Chemicals to find a Jokerized zombie Alfred (dug up from his grave and resurrected) waiting for him. Joker then appears, decked out in the new shiny blue Bat-suit. Across town, Batgirl re-opens her old clocktower HQ and becomes Oracle for the first time in many years. She initiates her “Batfall Protocol,” which sends a message out to all Gotham, organizing them to fight back against the evil clowns. When Mayor Dunch orders the GCPD to stand down and fall back, Commissioner Bullock resigns from his post, leading the GCPD into battle against the mayor’s wishes. Nightwing, Red Hood, Robin (Tim), Signal, Orphan, and Batwoman bust Punchline and the rest of Joker’s clowns. At Ace Chemicals, Batman and Joker fight each other. Harley Quinn takes down Joker, strapping a bomb to herself and another to Joker. Thus, Batman is forced to chase after Harley in order to save her life, an act that will presumably finally result in Joker’s death. Harley could have easily killed Joker then and there, but she doesn’t, citing that Batman (and Batman alone) must be responsible for his death. Batman saves Harley, who gets injured and goes into a coma. After returning to Ace Chemicals, Batman finds that Joker has deactivated his bomb and disappeared. (The epilogue to “The Joker War” occurs a week later. We’ll see it on our timeline ahead.)


<<< Rebirth Era Year 18 (Part 2) <<< ||| >>> Rebirth Era Year 19 (Part 2) >>>

  1. [1]COLLIN COLSHER: The Batman-less Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen Vol. 2 #8 occurs now. In this issue, creators Matt Fraction and Steve Lieber show a statue in honor of the original Atom, who is said to have been active as a hero in the 1940s, hinting at his time with the JSA. This statue is cute, but it should be ignored. The present day would have no memory of the Atom of the JSA at this juncture on our chronology. Likewise, Dan DiDio’s Metal Men Vol. 4 #4, which also goes right around here on our timeline, shows a Golden Age Robotman and references the fact that the JSA was active in the 1940s. Again, this is fun, but must be ignored for the same reasons as above. Plus, this was written right before DiDio was fired, during a time when he was trying to push in his ill-fated “Generations” reboot. Just as his reboot was snuffed-out, his linked JSA reference must also be cancelled. It’s possible that Fraction and Lieber were also in “Generations” mode when adding in their own 1940s reference. Sheesh. 2020 DCU continuity is a mess.
  2. [2]COLLIN COLSHER: The lead-up to this item, Teen Titans Vol. 6 #39-40, features Jakeem Thunder and his Johnny Thunder lighting bolt djinni. Note that Johnny Thunder’s status as a lightning elemental has been quietly restored thanks to Doomsday Clock. However, thanks to the Batman Who Laughs blocking Dr. Manhattan’s reboot at the conclusion of that series, the JSA has been restored to history, but present day memories of them have paradoxically been blocked. In other words, the timeline is mega-fucked right now.
  3. [3]COLLIN COLSHER: Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #12 is non-canon, impossible to fit into any chronology. It features Tim as Drake, Dick as Nightwing (in his proper Nightwing costume), Damian as Robin, Clayface as a villain, and Luke Fox as lead technical engineer at Wayne Enterprises. There’s no time where all of the above have aligned (or could even possibly align in the future). Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #13 Part 1 faces similar problems that render it non-canon. It takes place on April 22, Bruce and Damian are on good terms, Aquaman is active, Alfred is alive, Damian is a member of the Teen Titans, and both Superman and Batman are wearing their trunks-on-the-outside costumes. There’s no time where all of the above align (even if we remove one or two of the items to form a different combination).
  4. [4]COLLIN COLSHER: In January 2020, DC released Batman: The Caped Crusader Giant #1, a one-shot exclusive to Target stores only. This comic is non-canon as it is merely a toy tie-in for Spin Master action figures.
  5. [5]COLLIN COLSHER: Detective Comics #1027 Part 8 is a very cool Grant Morrison short about the vigilantism in Gotham prior to Batman’s debut. However, it is out-of-continuity.
  6. [6]COLLIN COLSHER: Here is the entire “Joker War” chronology, complete with the Batman-less tie-in issues (in bold). There are, of course, some nasty continuity errors…

    –Batman Vol. 3 #86-94 / Batman Secret Files #3 Part 5 (“THEIR DARK DESIGNS”) [“The Joker War” technically begins on final day of “Their Dark Designs”]
    –Nightwing Vol. 4 #70-73 / Red Hood: Outlaw #48
    –Nightwing Vol. 4 #74
    –Nightwing Vol. 4 #75
    Part 1
    –Detective Comics #1027 Part 12
    –Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 Part 2
    –Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 1
    –Batman Vol. 3 #95-98 (“THE JOKER WAR”) [Nightwing’s trip to Blüdhaven from Nightwing Vol. 4 #75 Part 2 overlaps with Batman Vol. 3 #95; Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 5 overlaps with Batman Vol. 3 #96]
    –Detective Comics #1025-1026 (“THE JOKER WAR: COLLATERAL DAMAGE”) [Batgirl Vol. 5 #47-48 overlaps with Detective Comics #1025-1026, going 100% prior to Batman Vol. 3 #99. But Batgirl Vol. 5 #48 has a terrible continuity error of Luke visiting Babs after meeting with Catwoman in Catwoman Vol. 5 #25, which doesn’t take place until Batman Vol. 3 #99. As such, the flashback in Batgirl Vol. 5 #48 should be summarily ignored.]
    –Batman Vol. 3 #99-100 (“THE JOKER WAR” Conclusion) [Catwoman Vol. 5 #25 happens immediately after the Bat-Family gathering in Batman Vol. 3 #99, thus overlapping with Batman Vol. 3 #99. A bogus editorial note in Catwoman Vol. 5 #25 says that Luke will go to visit Batgirl in “Batgirl #88“. Not only do they mean “Batgirl #48“, but we should also ignore this editorial note entirely as it is just plain wrong. Luke has already visited Babs, as seen in Batgirl Vol. 5 #48, which takes place decidedly before Batman Vol. #99. Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 2, Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 3, and Batman: The Joker War Zone #1 Part 4 all overlap with Batman Vol. 3 #99-100.]
    –Batgirl Vol. 5 #49
    –Batman Vol. 3 #100
    –fb from Batman Vol. 3 #101
    –Detective Comics #1028

    –Batman Vol. 3 #101

27 Responses to Rebirth Year Nineteen (Part 1)

  1. Antonio says:

    Hey Collin, how’s it going?
    I’ve just read your kind words for Dennis O’Neal in your blog and I couldn’t have used better words. He was a simple man who truly understood what it meant to be a hero.
    Batman’s biological fathers are Bob Kane and Bill Finger, but the ones who really raised him to become the man he is now, were Denny O’ Neal, Neal Adams and Frank Miller. But Miller wrote Year One and TDKR, whereas Denny wrote numerous Batman’s story which defined the Character from the 70’s on.
    I’ve recently read “Death Strikes at Midnight and Three”, I’m sure you’ve read that one. That is one great example of a simple story and at the same time so powerful and meaningful.
    That was Denny O’ Neal.
    The two main Batman’s witers of today are Snyder and King, but they should learn something from Denny. Snyder always wants to go gigantic. Never simple. Never flying low. King doesn’t seem to grasp the character completely and he gets lost here and there. Sometimes too sentimental, sometimes the fireworks he lit just don’t catch fire in the end.
    So thank you Collin for your words. Dennis O’ Neal meant so much to me. May he rest in peace forever and inspire today’s writers from up above. Wherever he is.

  2. Martin says:

    I find your mention of “many bizarre instances of characters being given false memories of an alternate reality upon meeting alternate-reality characters” fascinating considering the Lois Lane series which finished last Tuesday. It explicitly tackled this phenomenon, calling it “fracturing”, with Lois publishing a book revealing the nature of the multiverse and opening a discount Sanctuary called Unity House to help people struggling with conflicting memories from alternate timelines.

    • Hey Martin! I heard about Lois’ book coming out, but I didn’t realize it was about this subject. That’s really amazing. The first instance of fracturing (at least proto-fracturing) was after the original Crisis, although not quite the same, since folks were recalling fading memories of a false reality, not getting bogus memories upon meeting someone). The first real instance of this phenomenon is with Geoff Johns in Infinite Crisis—notably Power Girl gaining fake memories upon meeting Kal-L. Cut to today, Brian Michael Bendis and Greg Rucka are clearly big-time devotees of the concept, even going so far as to give us a technical term for it!

      While very interesting, I think fracturing might be a thing that could be overused or even abused at the expense of clean continuity. So far, though, I’m into it (I think). Let’s hope fracturing doesn’t become a crutch that writers rely on to ignore continuity. After all, there’s a thin line between a fracture and a fanwank.

  3. diego2024 says:

    Dear Colin: we know that even your head is trying to recover from the chronological chaos created by DC with Justice League #39 and Doomsday Clock, but now “Three Jokers” from Black Label has arrived,
    ¿is it too soon to ask you what you will do with it? ¿will you put it in the canon or not? ¿will you wait until it has been published in full?

    By the way, i love your article “A tale of two reboots” !!!

    • Hi Diego! Definitely waiting until it’s published in full before making any moves there. There are a lot of continuity questions that need to be answered—and I’m hoping Three Jokers and Metal provide them.

      And the Tale of Two Reboots (now three including the epilogue to Flash Forward) still continues!

  4. Antonio says:

    Yes, and Don’t forget I’ve just finished reading Teen Titans Annual 2 in which Damian leaves… but in Joker War he’s still Robin… go figures…
    The DC guys just need to get things back together again or we’ll go crazy

    • Antonio says:

      I think Three Jokers has 3 possible collocations: 1) Black Label out of continuity
      2) Actually It doesn’t contradict anything in the Modern Age (could infact very well be considered one of the last stories of that timeline) and so go there
      3) Going right before The Laughing House and Doomsday Clock (Batman is wearing the exact same costume and Alfred is in it) in Year 17 of the Rebirth Era.

      I don’t think in any possible way it can go after Joker War or Dark Nights Death Metal.

      • Again, I’m waiting until the end before making judgment, but here’s my headcanon so far…

        1) I think it’s 100% canon—as it references the 3 Jokers revelation made in multiple canon comics.
        2) I’d never place it in the Modern Age—as it reads definitively as a Rebirth Era comic. Joe Chill still alive, 3 Jokers revelation only ever mentioned in New 52/Rebirth (and never prior), etc… etc… Johns loves to canonize the Modern Age. Doomsday Clock alone had dozens of references to the Modern Age, despite being a Rebirth Era title.
        3) It should definitely go prior to Alfred’s death, of course. And I think, as a Johns story further developing a prior Alan Moore work, it should go in-and-around Doomsday Clock, maybe just afterward. Again, a lot could happen… and solicitations and rumors hint that the story will have a huge impact.

    • Hey Antonio! There are a bunch of issues that I haven’t placed due to shaky lingering continuity questions. I’m hoping that Metal provides more answers—specifically as to what soft reboot effects Doomsday Clock #12 and the epilogue to Flash Forward had upon the canon.

      Here a few Batman or Batman-related issues that contain references to things that were previously non-canon prior to Doomsday Clock (but which still seem to contradict Rebirth canon)…

      –Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #12-17
      –Legion of Super-Heroes Vol. 8 #2
      –Superman Vol. 5 #19 Part 2
      –Superman: Heroes #1 Part 2
      –Superman: Villains #1
      –Superman Vol. 5 #22-23
      –Action Comics #1022
      –Teen Titans Vol. 6 #42-44
      –Teen Titans Vol. 6 Annual #2
      –Green Lantern 80th Anniversary 100-Page Super Spectacular
      –Robin 80th Anniversary 100-Page Spectacular

      Honestly, not too many issues… the Superman stuff is here mostly because of Ma and Pa Kent whereas the Titans stuff is here because the prior arc has Jakeem Thunder and Johnny Thunderbolt. Seems like Ma and Pa Kent might have been re-instated and the JSA returned to present day existence but with collective memory of their 1940s past still blocked. The Robin Special and some of the Gotham Nights books allude to Spoiler having been a Robin. Again, though, I’m waiting for at least a sliver more confirmation from Metal before I take action on the above.

      Metal itself shows the JSA, which seems to point toward Doomsday Clock/Flash Forward having reinstated the JSA in present day but blocked some memory of their past history (as in what we literally saw in “Justice/Doom War”).

  5. Ayaan says:

    Hi Collin nice reading order you have there, I just wanted to point a few things out. In the New Justice league run 40-52 should be placed before city of bane because we see Alfred alive in Justice League#40. Man I wish they never killed Alfred. Nice reading order you have Collin, The only thing I want to see is the batman giants a bit cause im into them. Anyways bye!

    • Hi Ayaan, thanks for your patronage! It’s very subtle, but the JL #40 Alfred appearance is actually a flashback. Batman sets his plane on autopilot to return home, triggering the memory of how, prior to this, he would have Alfred remote-pilot it back (along with some friendly banter). Now, with Alfred dead, Batman sits in silence and simply says “autopilot.”

      And all the Batman Giants have been added! Which ones am I missing?

      • Ayaan says:

        Oh Ok Collin, and for the giants I mean the Batman Gotham Knights Dc Digital Firsts line. I have noticed you have included some but some of the other issues are based on other giants so yeah. I also have a question for The Grim Knight Batman one-shot where would place that.

        • Ayaan says:

          I made a mistake since you already knew about the Gotham Knights thing. About the Joker War can you add the tie ins that are involved, I know they aren’t with Batman but it can help the chronology. Btw there are multiple resources for a Joker war order. I think if you include this I think it can be helpful. Thanks and sorry

          • No need for apologies! Typically, I don’t include any issues that don’t feature Batman, but I’m not opposed to adding in a footnote about the “Joker War” tie-ins that don’t feature Batman. It’ll have to wait until the arc wraps, though.

        • Hey Ayann, I’m holding off on placing Batman: Gotham Nights Vol. 3 #12-17 because some of those issues allude to Spoiler having been a Robin, and some of the others seem to not fit that easily into current continuity for various other reasons. There’s a possibility that they all might go in the new post-Metal continuity come December, but we’ll see.

          The Grim Knight one-shot overlaps with “Laughing House” (the first part of The Batman Who Laughs series), occurring immediately after the Grim Knight kidnaps Jim Gordon.

  6. Antonio says:

    Yes… I missed the Joe Chill thing… and so three jokers can’t go there. I wonder why so many stories of the modern age have been canonized in the rebirth era and other great ones like joe chill in hell didn’t.
    But.. do you like the idea of “it never was only one joker… there’s always been 3 of them”?
    I think it deminishes the character… I don’t know. I’d really lime to hear your opinion on the matter, even though it will end in october

    • Yeah, I certainly don’t love the idea of multiple Jokers. I agree that it could potentially diminish the character and, besides that, it’s a little too-on-the-nose and narratively strange-beyond-necessity. (One could easily make the same argument that there have been multiple Catwomen, multiple Riddlers, multiple Two-Faces, etc, using Johns’ very same logic.) However, I’ll wait until this series is over before handing out any judgement, praise, or condemnation. After all, a sequel to Watchmen was a TERRIBLE idea, but Johns delivered quite well with Doomsday Clock, and the HBO series was also quite good. There hasn’t been this much hype for a DC comic since… Johns last big comic, LOL. Here’s to hoping it’s good. Because of the hype, my expectations are high, and that’s a dangerous place for my expectations to be.

      I’ll be sure to let you know what I think come October/November! I’m sure I’ll have a lot to say about Metal too.

      • Teo says:

        Heh, maybe there WILL be multiple Riddler’s, Two-Faces etc. In Geoff’s wild meta ride, anything is possible!

        Also just wanted to say I’ve been a frequent lurker on this site for about 4 years now, you’re doing amazing work! Keep it up!

        • Hey Teo, thanks for commenting. Glad to have you with me aboard planet Johns, where we have no choice but to ride along. I think the trip’s been good so far, but we’ll see if he sticks the landing. And thanks for being a site patron for so long! I truly appreciate it.

  7. Antonio says:

    Hey Collin, Antonio here.
    I just noticed that you moved everything “one year later” and we’re now in Year 19… did you do that in order to better include everything?
    I also noticed that in the Rebirth Era there’s no place for Dark Victory. Do you like the fact that Dick basically debuted in Year One? I find that pretty ridiculous… but that’s another one from Tom King…

    I hope everything is ok with you…

    • Hey Antonio. I simply got rid of Year Zero and now begin with Year One. There is no reason to have a Year Zero for the Rebirth timeline. That is a New 52 thing only, so the correction has been made. (Snyder’s “Zero Year” has been mashed-up with Miller’s “Year One,” and a handful of Golden and Silver Age tales. Basically, Rebirth contains the ultimate Year One mash-up.)

      And you aren’t the only one pissed about Tom King moving Robin into Year One. I got a lot of angry messages about it, many of which telling me to ignore and move Robin back to Year Two or Year Three. But, it’s pretty clear that King, with DiDio’s blessing, wanted it the way it is, so that’s the way I have it—for better or worse.

  8. Pocok says:

    Hello Collin, hope you are doing okay!

    I know a lot of Joker War tie-ins aren’t represent Batman in there, but I’m curious, can you help me out their proper placement? Like Catwoman 25-26, Batgirl 47-49, Red Hood 48, the remaining Nightwing issues etc.

    Thank you so much in advance if you do so!

    • Doing well. So many people have asked me to add in the tie-ins, you aren’t alone! I’ll definitely include a note about the full Joker War chronology at some point soon.

    • Here is the order. There are, of course, some nasty continuity errors…

      –Batman Vol. 3 #86-94 / Batman Secret Files #3 Part 5 (“THEIR DARK DESIGNS”) [Joker War technically begins on final day of “Their Dark Designs”]
      –Nightwing Vol. 4 #70-73 / Red Hood: Outlaw #48
      –Nightwing Vol. 4 #74
      –Detective Comics #1027 Part 12
      –Batman Vol. 3 #95-98 (“THE JOKER WAR”)
      –Detective Comics #1025-1026 (“THE JOKER WAR: COLLATERAL DAMAGE”) [Batgirl Vol. 5 #47-48 overlaps with Detective Comics #1025-1026, going 100% prior to Batman Vol. 3 #99. But Batgirl Vol. 5 #48 has a terrible continuity error of Luke visiting Babs after meeting with Catwoman in Catwoman Vol. 5 #25, which doesn’t take place until Batman Vol. 3 #99. The flashback in Batgirl Vol. 5 #48 should be summarily ignored.]
      –Batman Vol. 3 #99-100 (“THE JOKER WAR” Conclusion) [Catwoman Vol. 5 #25 happens immediately after the Bat-Family gathering in Batman Vol. 3 #99, thus overlapping with Batman Vol. 3 #99. A bogus editorial note in Catwoman Vol. 5 #25 says that Luke will go to visit Batgirl in “Batgirl #88“. Not only do they mean “Batgirl #48“, but we should also ignore this editorial note entirely as it is just plain wrong. Luke has ALREADY visited Babs, as seen in Batgirl Vol. 5 #48, which takes place decidedly before Batman Vol. #99.]
      –Batgirl Vol. 5 #49
      –Nightwing Vol. 4 #75
      –Batman Vol. 3 #100 Epilogue
      –Catwoman Vol. 5 #26

      • Pocok says:

        Thank you so much!

        2 observations tho: Nightwing #75 and Catwoman #26 not out yet, so can their placement alter in the future maybe a bit?

        Also where does Joker Warzone fit into?

        • Yes, Nightwing #75 and Catwoman #26 and Batigirl #50, all speculation, since they are not yet released.

          Joker War Zone Part 1 (Joker and Bane) occurs somewhere prior to Batman #95.
          Joker War Zone Part 2 (Fox family) overlaps with Batman #100.
          Joker War Zone Part 3 (Spoiler and Orphan) overlaps with Batman #100.
          Joker War Zone Part 4 (Queen Ivy) overlaps with Batman #100.
          Joker War Zone Part 5 (Clownhunter) overlaps with Batman #96.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *